The defence has questioned the quality of the Independent Police Investigative Directorate (IPID) investigation in the matter of suspended Ekurhuleni Metropolitan Police Department (EMPD) Deputy Chief Julius Mkhwanazi and five others.

Mkhwanazi and his co-accused face charges including murder and defeating the ends of justice over the killing of Brakpan businessman Emmanuel Mbense.

ALSO READ:

Emmanuel Mbense case: Defence expected to conclude cross-examining IPID’s Nomsa Masuku

Mkhwanazi defence hits back at State over gap in Mbense murder case

Mbense murder trial: Off-duty officer questioned over presence at crime scene

The defence has honed in on IPID’s reliance on the affidavit of a former South African Police Service (SAPS) Special Force marksman, Matipandile Sotheni, who is accused of killing Marius van der Erwe, known as "Witness D" at the Madlanga Commission.

His affidavit was read into the record as the State sought to present him as a credible and honest witness whose version could implicate some of the accused in the Mbense case.

A senior prosecutor also told the court at the time that he believed Sotheni’s version to be true.

However, the defence pointed to a striking contradiction.

In Sotheni’s own murder case, the State has opposed his bail, alleging that he lied about his whereabouts and linking him to Van der Merwe’s murder.

Mkhwanazi’s lawyer, Peter Wilkins, said IPID investigator Nomsa Masuku should have confronted these contradictions before relying on Sotheni’s affidavit in this case.

“The current investigation is not up to standard. At the very least, reference should have been had of the opposing affidavit in Sotheni’s case before you relied on Sotheni’s affidavit as being a credible, honest witness.”

The defence is using the contradiction to point out that the State’s case against Mkhwanazi is built on an investigation that failed to test key evidence and failed to reconcile conflicting versions before placing them before the court.

The bail application continues on Friday.

Never miss a major story. Get breaking news and the latest developments from South Africa and beyond as they happen.