On Thursday, the Brakpan Magistrates Court heard that the second accused in the case against suspended Ekurhuleni Metropolitan Police Department (EMPD) Deputy Chief Julius Mkhwanazi and five others was off duty when he chose to respond to the scene at Emmanuel Mbense’s home.

Former police Sergeant Bhekokwakhe Sibande placed himself at the scene where Mbense was allegedly assaulted and killed, but denied any involvement in the crime.

ALSO READ:

Bail proceedings in Emmanuel Mbense murder case expected to continue

Defence challenges State's common purpose argument in Julius Mkhwanazi murder bail hearing

Emmanuel Mbense murder: Defence challenges State for referring to accused as 'a group'

IPID's investigator concedes accused No 1 was not inside the house during Mbense's alleged assault

The six are currently applying to be released on bail after being charged with Mbense's murder and disposing of his body.

Defence advocate states it cannot be assumed that Sibande was one of the two uniformed police officers referred to by Madlanga Commission witness Marius van der Merwe.

The investigating officer told the court that the South African Police Service's (SAPS) automatic vehicle location system placed Sibande and other officers at the scene.

The court also heard Sibande left his home after going off duty and drove a state vehicle to the scene after seeing a WhatsApp message.

The investigating officer questioned this decision.

"SAPS doesn't run out of members to attend the crime scene when it's necessary," she said. "If you are off duty, you are off duty; somebody on duty must go and attend the scene."

Sibande insisted he left the scene after other officials arrived.

However, the witness told the court that every crime scene in the country belongs to the SAPS, and no officer may leave a scene to outside officials without a proper handover.

She added that there was no evidence of Sibande or his SAPS colleagues handing over the scene to senior SAPS officials.

The defence maintains Sibande was never in charge of the scene, found other officers there, and left when his assistance was no longer needed.

Never miss a major story. Get breaking news and the latest developments from South Africa and beyond as they happen.