The defence in the murder case against suspended EMPD deputy chief Julius Mkhwanazi and five co-accused is challenging the State's reliance on common purpose to hold all the accused liable for the alleged murder, robbery and defeating the ends of justice in the 2022 killing of businessman Emmanuel Mbense.
The state alleges that members of the South African Police Service (SAPS), Ekurhuleni Metropolitan Police Department (EMPD), and private security worked together to commit the crimes.
ALSO READ:
Emmanuel Mbense murder: Defence challenges State for referring to accused as 'a group'
Emmanuel Mbense murder: Bail bid for Julius Mkhwanazi, others expected to continue
However, the defence says the state must prove each accused's individual role.
During cross-examination, investigating officer Nomsa Masuku was challenged over her repeated reference to the accused as “a group”.
The defence argued that there is no evidence that accused number one, Cobus Janse van Rensburg, took part in Mbense's assault or robbery, and that he had already left the scene when the decision was allegedly taken to contact General Khan or Mkhwanazi about Mbense's body.
When pressed to accept that Janse van Rensburg could therefore not have been part of that group, Masuku said,
"It was a crime scene because someone died. They were supposed to report it to the local police and not make alternative arrangements."
Masuku also relied on a meeting among the accused as evidence of a plan to rob and kill Mbense, but under cross-examination conceded there was no evidence of an agreement to commit the crime.
For the state to rely on common purpose, it must establish, among other things, that the accused had a prior agreement, whether expressed or implied, to commit the crime, or actively associated themselves with its commission.
Defence counsel for Janse van Rensburg, Advocate Marius, then put it to Masuku:
“I want to put it to you, pertaining to applicant number one, that there is no case against him. There is no strong case against applicant number one in law... "
The bail hearing has now been postponed to August 27.
Never miss a major story. Get breaking news and the latest developments from South Africa and beyond as they happen.