The murder case against suspended Ekurhuleni Metropolitan Police Department (EMPD) Deputy Chief Julius Mkhwanazi and five co-accused returns to the Brakpan Magistrates Court on Thursday, with bail proceedings expected to continue.

The defence is continuing its cross-examination of the State’s witness, the Independent Police Investigative Directorate (IPID)’s lead investigator in the Emmanuel Mbense murder case.

ALSO READ:

Defence challenges State's common purpose argument in Julius Mkhwanazi murder bail hearing

Emmanuel Mbense murder: Defence challenges State for referring to accused as 'a group'

IPID's investigator concedes accused No 1 was not inside the house during Mbense's alleged assault

Mkhwanazi and his five co-accused face charges including murder, robbery with aggravating circumstances and defeating the ends of justice.

The charges emanate from the death of the Brakpan businessman, who was allegedly tortured, robbed and killed before his body was dumped at a dam near Nigel.

The State alleges that EMPD, the South African Police Service (SAPS) and private security officers planned the killing of Mbense and then agreed to keep the alleged plot a secret, with anyone who spoke out allegedly threatened with death.

The case has also been shadowed by the deaths of potential witnesses, with one person who allegedly blew the whistle on the matter, Marius Van Der Merwe, gunned down in front of his family in December.

Two other potential witnesses were also killed, while the man alleged to have been a key figure in Mbense’s murder, Wiandre Pretorius, died by suicide a few months ago.

IPID's lead investigator, Nomsa Masuku, is currently on the witness stand.

She has already been forced to make concessions under cross-examination regarding accused number one, Cobus Janse Van Rensburg, and his precise alleged role in the crimes.

Masuku has also raised the alarm over what she described as perceived preferential treatment of the accused.

Masuku told the court last week that the six accused, arrested three weeks ago, are yet to see the inside of prison despite J7 detention warrants and a court order directing that they be detained in prison.

Detention warrants seen by Eyewitness News indicate the accused were to be held at the Johannesburg Prison, pending the outcome of their bail application.

Instead, they remained at Brakpan Police Station, where they allegedly received a steady stream of visitors and special food deliveries.

Masuku said her name was used to justify disregarding the detention court order.

“The station commander was not aware. If the station commander was saying I rearranged, then I was going to understand. But even if she rearranged, that's a court order that even the national commissioner cannot overrule to say the court said prison. Even the minister cannot [change the order].”

Concerns about possible favouritism towards Mkhwanazi and his co-accused are now also being raised within police ranks.

Masuku said the difference in how the accused appear to be treated could damage public confidence in the justice system.

“Your worship, from the conduct to the community, it will appear like they are being done favours, compared to other accused person when they are detained.”

Last Wednesday, when court proceedings adjourned, Masuku asked the court to keep the accused at the Benoni and Germiston police stations ahead of their court appearances in other matters.

Never miss a major story. Get breaking news and the latest developments from South Africa and beyond as they happen.