The defence in the case against suspended Ekurhuleni Metro Police Department (EMPD) deputy chief Julius Mkhwanazi and five others zeroed in on a critical gap in the State’s case: that Mkhwanazi was not present when Emmanuel Mbense was allegedly assaulted and killed.
It challenged the investigating officer’s version that there was a “prior agreement” to rob, assault, and kill Mbense.
ALSO READ:
Emmanuel Mbense murder: Bail bid for Julius Mkhwanazi, co-accused set to resume
Emmanuel Mbense's post-mortem details laid bare in court
Mbense murder trial: Off-duty officer questioned over presence at crime scene
Defence challenges State's common purpose argument in Julius Mkhwanazi murder bail hearing
Mkhwanazi and his co-accused are facing charges including murder and defeating the ends of justice linked to the alleged killing and dumping of Mbense’s body in 2022.
The accused have been fighting to be released on bail in the Brakpan Magistrates Court since their arrest nearly a month ago.
Mkhwanazi’s lawyer, Peter Wilkins, pressed Independent Police Investigative Directorate (IPID) lead investigator Nomsa Masuku on why the State’s charge sheet does not refer to a prior agreement to kill or rob Mbense, noting this was only mentioned after he objected to a murder charge.
"I put it to you that the reason why the State does not mention a prior meeting at which this was agreed upon is because there is no such evidence in your docket," Wilkins said.
Masuku conceded that Mkhwanazi was not part of the alleged prior meetings, but refused to concede that Mbense was already dead when Mkhwanazi arrived at the scene and could only face a charge of accessory after the fact.
"I cannot agree to say when he joined, the deceased was already dead because we don't have certification of death from the house," Masuku said. "So, I cannot say when the deceased was moved from the house; he was already dead. I don't know. Maybe he had fainted. He was going to simply be alive. I don't know, sir. But the certification is only on the 15th, the following day afternoon."
Never miss a major story. Get breaking news and the latest developments from South Africa and beyond as they happen.