The rogue search for President Cyril Ramaphosa’s stolen US dollars in Namibia dominated debate in the Western Cape High Court on Thursday, as the African Transformation Movement (ATM) cast doubt on what really happened at a meeting in no-man’s land.

The party is opposing the president’s application challenging the lawfulness of an independent panel report on Phala Phala that could lead to his impeachment.

ALSO READ:

ATM snubs court on deciding if there’s enough evidence for Ramaphosa to face impeachment

ATM warns court against halting Ramaphosa Phala Phala impeachment review

Phala Phala panel report: Ramaphosa's team slams 'absurd' reporting expectations

Veracity of evidence related to Ramaphosa's Phala Phala matter under scrutiny in court

The ATM has argued that it was relevant for the panel to question the source of the $580,000 stolen from his Phala Phala farm, saying it would help determine whether the president was doing other paid work in violation of the Constitution.

The ATM contends that the independent panel, appointed by Parliament in 2022, correctly executed its role to probe the transaction that led to wads of US dollars being concealed on the president’s farm.

ATM advocate Kessler Perumalsamy also called into question statements from Namibian authorities as to why Ramaphosa’s former special adviser, Bejani Chauke, and his head of security, Wally Rhoode, travelled to Namibia four months after the theft of the money in June 2020.

"General Rhoode was in Namibia to conduct an investigation on the behest of the President. That investigation wasn’t public or made known. It was secretive, and it was fundamentally to protect a private interest, not a public interest. The private interest of the president. "

The ATM contends it would have been unusual for both Chauke and Rhoode to travel to a foreign country of their own volition, while Namibian authorities said it was to discuss a suspect in the Phala Phala burglary, David Immanuela.

"The explanation of why Mr Chauke and General Rhoode was patently untrue. "

Judge President Nolwazi Mabindla-Boqwana questioned whether these events presented sufficient evidence to suggest Ramaphosa acted unlawfully.

Never miss a major story. Get breaking news and the latest developments from South Africa and beyond as they happen.