The African Transformation Movement (ATM) said it’s not for a court to decide whether sufficient evidence exists for President Cyril Ramaphosa to face impeachment.

It’s opposing an application brought by Ramaphosa in the Western Cape High Court to have the report, which has led to a parliamentary inquiry into his conduct, set aside.

ALSO READ:

ATM warns court against halting Ramaphosa Phala Phala impeachment review

Phala Phala panel report: Ramaphosa's team slams 'absurd' reporting expectations

Veracity of evidence related to Ramaphosa's Phala Phala matter under scrutiny in court

The ATM said Ramaphosa owes South Africans explanations about theft of US dollars from his Phala Phala farm in 2020, and it does not believe he will suffer a grave injustice to be impeached.

Ramaphosa said it would be profoundly humiliating to face impeachment on untested and insufficient evidence and for the process to be used by his political opponents to settle scores.

His advocate, Wim Trengove, said that the independent panel, which compiled the report on which the Parliamentary inquiry is based, did not execute their role adequately and failed to filter whether the evidence put before it justifies an impeachment hearing.

“We submit with respect that it’s pointless to give the president an opportunity to respond if the ultimate exercise is a mechanical determination of whether there’s a prima facie case.”

However, Advocate Anton Katz, representing the ATM, said Ramaphosa can’t use the reputation argument to stave off impeachment.

The ATM originally tabled the parliamentary motion containing four charges for Ramaphosa’s impeachment.

“The concerns raised should have been thought of by the president before he stashed $500,000 [in] cash in a sofa,” Katz said.

Trengove hit back, “I object to that. It’s an insult, it’s gratuitous and it’s made for populist reasons.”

The ATM will continue with its arguments on Thursday, followed by the Economic Freedom Fighters (EFF) and the uMkhonto weSizwe (MK) Party, which are also opposing the application, along with United Africans Transformation (UAT), which will present its arguments on Friday.

Never miss a major story. Get breaking news and the latest developments from South Africa and beyond as they happen.