The veracity of evidence related to the Phala Phala matter is under scrutiny in the Western Cape High Court on Wednesday, and whether it was sufficient to subject President Cyril Ramaphosa to impeachment.

Ramaphosa’s legal counsel has told the court Ramaphosa, at all times, acted in good faith when it came to light that US dollars had been stolen from his Limpopo farm in 2020.

ALSO READ:

Ramaphosa’s impeachment challenge: High Court to spotlight judgement of 3 jurists

Ramaphosa's counsel confident Western Cape High Court won't unreasonably delay impeachment report review

Gana says impeachment inquiry not distracted by Ramaphosa’s legal challenges

He’s argued that the independent panel that suggested he may have acted in bad faith and did not sufficiently weigh up the information put before it.

Ramaphosa is asking the court to review and set aside the report that has given rise to the Section 89 parliamentary inquiry.

Advocate Wim Trengove has argued that the independent panel appointed by Parliament in 2022 misinterpreted the National Assembly’s rules on impeachment.

He has told the court that the panel simply accepted the evidence put before it as sufficient to determine that President Ramaphosa may have a case of misconduct to answer to.

“The panel should have asked itself, not only whether there’s sufficient evidence, but whether there is sufficient evidence that the president acted wilfully and in bad faith.”

Trengove said Ramaphosa’s version of events was not weighed up against the unsubstantiated allegations made by former spy boss Arthur Fraser, who blew the lid off the Phala Phala saga.

“They recited lots of things, but they didn’t weigh up anything. They simply concluded: there are these allegations against the president and, therefore, there’s a prima facie case.”

The hearing continues.

Never miss a major story. Get breaking news and the latest developments from South Africa and beyond as they happen.