President Cyril Ramaphosa doesn’t believe any harm will be done if Parliament holds off on his impeachment hearing for a few more months, until the court has considered the report that has triggered the inquiry.
On Wednesday, his lawyer, Advocate Wim Trengove, argued in the Western Cape High Court that Ramaphosa is entitled to protection from the court because the process is demeaning.
ALSO READ:
MK Party, ATM pour cold water on Ramaphosa's bid to evade impeachment inquiry
Ramaphosa questions if Parliament has sufficient evidence to justify his impeachment
Impeachment process: Opposition parties argue Ramaphosa can't evade scrutiny
Proceedings are set to continue for a second day on Thursday, Trengove expected to respond to arguments from opposition parties that the president is trying to evade accountability.
Ramaphosa is disputing that the evidence contained in a report compiled under the leadership of former Chief Justice Sandile Ngcobo is sufficient to give rise to impeachable charges against him.
Advocate Trengove has told the court that the President’s reputation would be harmed, and he would be publicly humiliated if he were to face an inquiry on spurious charges.
“It is a scant price if the risk to which you expose the president without that protection is that he would be publicly pilloried as a president who committed a grievous offence.”
But Judge Andre le Grange, one of three hearing the case, put it to Trengove that former President Nelson Mandela once appeared in court in a matter involving the SA Rugby Union.
Le Grange questioned whether the impeachment process may, in fact, exonerate rather than humiliate the President.
Trengove, who represented Mandela in that case, said Mandela appeared as a witness in that matter.
“Even to put a president on trial without good reason is a momentous step which should not be taken lightly.”
Meanwhile, opposition parties have argued that they have a duty to hold the president accountable on behalf of ordinary South Africans, and that the High Court could not overturn an order handed down by the country’s top court that it should proceed with impeachment proceedings.
RAMAPHOSA EXERCISING CONSTITUTIONAL RIGHT
Presidential spokesperson Vincent Magwenya said Ramaphosa is exercising his constitutional right by asking the courts to stop Parliament's impeachment process.
Magwenya argued that the president isn't fleeing accountability
“What the President is doing is simply exercising his rights, in that you cannot have a flawed report forming the basis for a removal of the president is just that simple.
“I will let you argue the other issues in whichever way you do, but from the President's view, it’s as simple as that. It’s not like the president is spending 20 years trying to dodge a trial here.”
Additional reporting by Dimakatso Leshoro
Never miss a major story. Get breaking news and the latest developments from South Africa and beyond as they happen.