The uMkhonto weSizwe (MK) Party believes President Cyril Ramaphosa is wasting the court’s time by trying to interdict his Parliamentary impeachment proceedings.

Speaking outside the courthouse on Wednesday, where he was once the judge president, MK Party parliamentary leader John Hlophe said the Western Cape High Court does not have the competence to overturn a ruling by the Constitutional Court that Parliament begins an inquiry into the theft of US Dollars from Ramaphosa’s farm.

ALSO READ:

Court to hear Ramaphosa's bid to stop impeachment inquiry

Parliament’s Impeachment Committee’s work will continue despite legal threats - Gana

Opposition parties push for Impeachment Committee to mandate President Ramaphosa to appear in person

Speaker Thoko Didiza under fire for refusing to oppose Ramaphosa's interdict

The president wants Parliament to stay its impeachment proceedings until the court has reviewed the report that has given rise to the inquiry, which he believes is fatally flawed.

“The Constitutional Court is the final court of appeal in the land. There’s no further appeal. Once it makes a ruling, there’s no other court that has competent jurisdiction to entertain the matter. There is case law to that effect.”

At the same time, the African Transformation Movement (ATM)’s parliamentary leader, Vuyo Zungula, does not believe Ramaphosa has provided solid reasons to the Western Cape High Court to prove that he will suffer irreparable harm and prejudice if impeachment proceedings against him continue.



Zungula initiated the impeachment proceedings against Ramaphosa in 2022, but the National Assembly voted down the report that Ramaphosa now seeks to review in a separate matter.

On Wednesday, Ramaphosa is asking the court to halt Parliament’s impeachment inquiry until the court can consider his review application in September.

The ATM will be opposing the application.

“Our strong argument is to say you can’t elevate the perceived reputational harm of the president over the constitutional obligations of Parliament to hold him accountable. That is our argument for today [Wednesday].”

RAMAPHOSA WANTS TO BE SPARED HUMILIATION

Meanwhile, President Cyril Ramaphosa believes he will suffer public humiliation if Parliament continues with impeachment proceedings against him until the High Court has reviewed the report that has given rise to the inquiry.

His legal representative, Wim Trengrove, has told a full bench of the Western Cape division, which is considering the interdict application, that it’s “political hogwash” that the president doesn’t want to explain his side of the events following the theft of US dollars from his Phala Phala farm.

Trengrove says the interdict would serve only a limited purpose to allow the Western Cape High Court to review the report, which Ramaphosa believes contains insufficient evidence to amount to a misconduct case against him.

"The fact of a public inquiry is already humiliating to the president and a humiliation against which the act protects him. Let me make it quite clear, it is the holding of an inquiry which, under the Act, may only start if there’s a lawful report, and the president seeks to protect himself against that inquiry because he has explained that it is punitive. The Constitutional Court has held that it’s punitive."

Never miss a major story. Get breaking news and the latest developments from South Africa and beyond as they happen.