President Cyril Ramaphosa has questioned whether Parliament has sufficient evidence before it to suggest he acted in bad faith and should face impeachment over events related to the theft of US dollars from his farm six years ago.
His lawyer, Advocate Wim Trengove, told the Western Cape High Court that the president would be publicly humiliated if he were to be subjected to oral testimony before evidence contained in an independent panel report was judicially reviewed.
ALSO READ:
MK Party, ATM pour cold water on Ramaphosa's bid to evade impeachment inquiry
Court to hear Ramaphosa's bid to stop impeachment inquiry
Parliament’s Impeachment Committee’s work will continue despite legal threats - Gana
Opposition parties push for Impeachment Committee to mandate President Ramaphosa to appear in person
Speaker Thoko Didiza under fire for refusing to oppose Ramaphosa's interdict
Ramaphosa wants the Western Cape High Court to stay proceedings until then, with Trengove telling the court no harm would be suffered if proceedings were stalled for two to three months.
Trengove said the independent panel appointed by Parliament in 2022 failed to sufficiently consider whether the evidence put before it was sufficient to suggest that the president had misconducted himself.
"For the misconduct to reach the level of an impeachable offence, you must find that the President intentionally transgressed the rules," Trengove said. "In other words, that he knew of the rules, and he intentionally transgressed them."
Trengove believes the panel erred in its duties and that impeachment proceedings should not continue until such time as the court has reviewed the Section 89 report.
"Is there prima facie evidence that the president acted in bad faith? It never asked that question," he said.
Trengove said the president deserved to be protected under Parliament’s rules against a process that was not based on sufficient evidence.
Never miss a major story. Get breaking news and the latest developments from South Africa and beyond as they happen.