The Board of Healthcare Funders (BHF), which represents private medical aid schemes, has heard that its litigation against the National Health Insurance (NHI) could be protracted for at least a decade.
With several cases lodged by various organisations across the country’s courts, the BHF’s lead attorney on the matter, Neil Kirby, said the cases are worth pursuing because of the impact the NHI could have on the quality of healthcare.
ALSO READ:
ConCourt reserves judgment in NHI challenge
Parly argues BHF hasn’t amply justified why NHI case belongs in ConCourt
NHI Act legal challenge: BHF denies backdoor attack in the Constitutional Court
However, a public health specialist, Wits University’s Professor Sharon Fonn, is advising the sector to ditch the court cases and instead engage in dialogue to address the concerns.
In May, the Constitutional Court heard arguments in the BHF’s case challenging the public participation aspect of Parliament passing the NHI bill.
That judgment could affect the president’s appeal against a High Court ruling that compels him to produce the record that led to his decision to sign the bill into law in 2024.
Kirby told the organisation’s annual conference that the issue is not the principle of universal access to healthcare, but the standard at which that healthcare will be provided.
“We have to get this right from a legal point of view, otherwise it’s a slippery slope from an application of a Constitution like ours.”
Meanwhile, Fonn said that while the proposed NHI Fund in its current form has shortcomings, legal challenges are not the way to resolve them.
“I think we lack the kind of leadership we need to move this forward. And that’s my point. Let’s get out of the courts, let’s get around a table. This is a policy process.”
Health economist Paula Armstrong has warned that the ever-rising cost of private health insurance is making it increasingly more unaffordable for the working class, forcing them to turn to public healthcare.