Parliament and the Board of Healthcare Funders (BHF) are at odds over whether the Constitutional Court has exclusive jurisdiction to hear the National Health Insurance challenge.
Parliament argues that the BHF has not sufficiently justified why the matter belongs before the apex court, saying its founding papers lack the necessary factual detail to trigger exclusive jurisdiction.
It contends that the BHF relies on a broad claim that Parliament failed in its constitutional duties, without providing sufficient detail in its initial affidavit.
ALSO READ: Constitutional Court judges raise concern over integrity of the NHI
The BHF has argued that its contention that the consultation process was superficial renders the legislation invalid.
This, it said, opens the gates for direct access to the apex court as a court of first and last instance.
Advocate Bruce Leech, on behalf of BHF, said only the Constitutional Court can decide this case.
“It is only this court, and it is only fitting and proper that it is this court that should do so. That debate has, by and large, been settled by Doctors for Life," said Leech
Leech told the court this matter warrants exceptional treatment.
“I appreciate the court's concerns about floodgates. But if there is a genuinely deserving case, and our submission is that this is a genuinely deserving case, then a litigant should be entitled to bring that case to the court with appropriate jurisdiction.”
Parliament’s legal team disagrees; advocate Ngwako Maenetje argued the case does not meet that threshold.
“The substance of this challenge, the core of it, is about the outcome. And there is no breach when the outcome is not what they sought, or the outcome is rational. They needed to apply for direct access for that and they haven't," said Maenetje.
Parliament maintains the application should be dismissed, or at most, reduced to a narrow question about whether there was a reasonable process when viewed as a whole.