The Constitutional Court has reserved judgement in the combined applications by the Board of Healthcare Funders (BHF) and the Western Cape government seeking to have the National Health Insurance (NHI) Act set aside.

Over two days, the applicants argued that both houses of Parliament failed to comply with constitutional requirements for meaningful public participation before passing the NHI bill.

They told the court the bill was rushed through Parliament, adhering to strict timelines without accommodating any amendments or necessary delays.

However, Parliament has rejected these claims, insisting proper processes were followed.

ALSO READ:

Advocate rejects claims of inadequate Gauteng public input in NHI legislation

ConCourt judges question affordability of NHI

ConCourt challenge against NHI seeks to preserve healthcare inequality: Dlamini-Zuma

The Western Cape government argued it was not given a fair opportunity to conduct hearings and submit its final mandate and report to the National Council of Provinces (NCOP).

The legal team spent most of its allocated time arguing that the absence of a report from the Gauteng province was another indicator that the NCOP failed to meet its constitutional obligations.

The Gauteng province has not made any submissions regarding the process.

The Western Cape seeks to redo the public participation process in the two provinces.

Meanwhile, the BHF has mounted a broader challenge targeting the process in the National Assembly.

It has asked the court to declare the law invalid, arguing lawmakers engaged in a “tick-box” exercise under the guise of public participation.

Parliament has pushed back against this assertion, noting that the applicants are not happy with the outcome.

The court’s ruling is expected to clarify the legal position in more than a dozen related cases challenging the NHI Act.