Judges in the Constitutional Court have questioned the affordability of the National Health Insurance (NHI) during the first day of the hearings.

They’ve raised concerns that the full cost of NHI is likely to be expensive, adding that the funding implications remain unclear as Parliament’s process is scrutinised.

This relates to the Constitutional Court challenge brought against Parliament’s public participation process by the Board of Healthcare Funders (BHF) and the Western Cape government.

ALSO READ:

Parly argues BHF hasn’t amply justified why NHI case belongs in ConCourt

Constitutional Court judges raise concern over integrity of the NHI

Justice Steven Majiedt said taxpayers have a right to know how much in additional taxes the NHI will cost.

“The one thing we cannot deny is that this is going be a very expensive system because what you are doing is amalgamating private and public medical healthcare. It's going to be frightfully expensive, so is it enough to say to an interested party: we are going to have to redirect from other parts of the budget, we are going to have to increase tax. The point is how much?"

Madjiet also raised concerns about corruption risks in the public health system and the powers of the benefits advisory committee, which will determine the provIsion of services under the NHI.

“This body with vast powers, unelected, with unconstrained powers as to what, as to what they cannot decide and what they can do. Where do we see the guidance as to how this vastly powerful unelected body, not accountable to parliament, will exercise their discretionary powers," said Majiedt.