He reminded the country that at every important moment in our history, we have come together as a nation to confront our challenges and forge a path into the future in dialogue with one another.

“Through the National Dialogue, we seek a shared vision of what it means to be a South African and develop a new national ethos and common value system,” he said.

An eminent persons panel was appointed. A national convention was held in August last year. But the idea of a national dialogue has never truly gained traction. It has been seen as half-baked, rushed and an expensive talk shop that is disconnected from the people on the ground.

Had it been effective, it could have provided an ideal platform for one of the hottest topics currently being navigated in a highly polarised environment.

The debate around xenophobia and illegal immigration pits the issues of constitutional rights and Pan-Africanism on the one side against demands for stricter border control and a swelling of undocumented foreigners on the other.

Underpinning it is high unemployment, sluggish growth and a scapegoating of foreigners for the failures of government to create jobs.

Populist groups and some political leaders lay the blame for structural problems on illegal immigrants. In response, the government, led by the President, has condemned violence and vigilantism.

President Ramaphosa addressed the nation on Sunday, announcing a series of interventions aimed at strengthening immigration enforcement, including intensified deportations, tighter border controls and increased inspections targeting undocumented foreign nationals and employers who hire them.

The president acknowledged growing public frustration over illegal immigration.

"Many South Africans are asking difficult but legitimate questions…They are concerned about safety, security, and the rule of law. These concerns are real. They deserve to be heard. They deserve to be addressed."

At the same time, he stressed that enforcing immigration laws remains the responsibility of the state and condemned vigilantism.

The discussion requires nuance from the government. Political leadership must straddle the line between condemnation and meeting the mood of the outraged public. Many are rightfully furious about porous borders and the pressure being added to the service delivery system by foreigners.

March and March leader Jacinta Ngobese-Zuma has rejected Ramaphosa's call for immigration enforcement to be left to the state. Ngobese-Zuma said the president's proposals fail to address the reality on the ground.

It would be naïve to suggest that a national dialogue or merely talking would resolve the current problem consuming the country.

But keep in mind that many of the people who are protesting about the issue voice a specific concern that the government is not listening to them on the issue. And while government leaders have made statements, they haven’t necessarily gone down to the ground to hear what protesters have to say on the topic.

The risk of dialogue, though, is that some leaders, like Ngobese-Zuma, have made wildly misleading and divisive claims that are just not true. GroundUp has roundly debunked a number of these – you can read that here. There is no point in getting people around a table if they are just going to make empty statements and be noisy.

Some academic institutions have regularly facilitated forums and civic education programs. They have attempted to create safe spaces to foster conversations and to promote social cohesion.

There are conversations that are being curated and organised, but not necessarily on the right level.

A National Dialogue could potentially have facilitated that discussion. However, it would have to be authentic and honest, and the government would have to truly listen. Protest leaders would also have to be willing to meaningfully engage.

Many would argue that merely talking would not solve the problem. Rather, it requires tangible action. Tightening border controls, improved enforcement of laws, stronger economic growth and job creation will help appease the outraged public.

But don’t underestimate the value of dialogue. As the President reminded us, at every important moment in our history, we have come together as a nation to confront our challenges and forge a path into the future in dialogue with one another.