There are no words to describe the depths of fear and panic that have gripped women across the Gauteng Province.
On the 9th of September 2026, Elizabeth "Tsontso" Moselakgomo went missing while out for a routine run.
When she didn't return home, her 8-year-old daughter raised the alarm. By the following day, there were posters all over social media and they were being shared widely.
I came across it in Germany, shared by a close friend in New York. But three days later, the search ended in absolute tragedy when a woman's body was discovered near the R21 in Rhodesfield, and on the 14th of September, it was positively identified as that of Moselakgomo.
Her murder opened a can of worms that the South African Police Service (SAPS) hadn't taken the public into confidence about: Moselakgomo was not the only woman who had been a victim of homicide recently.
On Tuesday evening, the Acting Police Minister, Firoz Cachalia, confirmed that the number of women’s bodies discovered in Ekurhuleni over the last two months stood at eight.
The bodies were found in and around Kempton Park and the victims, all women, were found partially clothed or naked. Nearly all bodies were found with visible bruising, and dumped in public spaces.
Several bodies were found near the R21 highway in Kempton Park/Rhodesfield; additional bodies were discovered in the Olifantsfontein/Clayville area, including one found near a local hotel and another in a river near Tembisa Mall; and another body was discovered near a church in Kwa-Thema.
While police have not formally confirmed whether the murders are connected, the similarities between them, particularly their geography and victim profiles (they're all women) have prompted authorities to establish a dedicated multi-disciplinary task team that is investigating whether this is the work of a serial killer or one or a group of people.
Not unexpectedly, these murders have caused panic in Gauteng. They are also extremely triggering for millions of women in South Africa who live in fear of gender-based violence and femicide (GBV-F) on a daily basis.
That our country is one of the world's GBV-F capitals is no secret. South Africa has one of the highest rates of femicide and interpersonal violence against women in the world, far exceeding the global average.
The rate at which women are killed by intimate partners in South Africa is five times higher than the global average.
Recent reports based on SAPS data show that thousands of women lose their lives to violence each year, with figures historically ranging between 3,000 and over 5,500 depending on the specific multi-year or annual reporting metrics. This indicates that between seven and 10 women are murdered daily in the country.
The statistics for rape and sexual assault are even more brutal. SAPS records roughly 40,000 to 43,000 explicit rape cases annually, with total sexual offenses exceeding 50,000 to 53,000 when including sexual assault. This amounts to an average of roughly 110 to 116 reported rapes every single day.
Crime statistics and monitoring organisations calculate that a rape is reported roughly once every 12 minutes. But while these numbers are debilitating, many organisations, including the Rape Crisis Cape Town Trust, note that official statistics only capture cases reported to authorities, leaving the true scope of sexual violence largely unmeasured.
A 2025 study by the Human Sciences Research Council on the prevalence of GBV-F indicates that 27% of women have experienced physical or sexual violence by a non-partner since age 15.
Looking at these numbers, one might think thousands of men are arrested annually for GBV-F crimes. This is not the case. The overall conviction rate for reported rape cases in South Africa is estimated to be between 4% and 9%.
Studies tracking the criminal justice system show that a large number of cases drop out or are closed at various stages before reaching a verdict. While police arrest suspects in about 50% to 57% of reported cases, only about 34% to 43% of arrested cases are formally accepted and charged for court.
Still, only fewer than 20% ever make it to trial and as stated, less than 10% result in a conviction.
These convictions rarely result in terms above the standard minimum of 10 to 15 years.
Studies and legal advisory groups such as Law For All have noted that while a significant portion of convicted rapists are legally eligible for life sentences based on the severity of their crimes, only a fraction of total convictions result in life terms, due in part to evidentiary hurdles, plea deals, or judicial discretion.
Under these circumstances, calls for the reinstatement of the death penalty for perpetrators of GBV-F are not irrational. I completely understand why, in light of the murder of Moselakgomo and the seven women thus far discovered in Gauteng, so many women in across South Africa are demanding that the government bring back capital punishment.
Decades of rising GBV-F statistics and a country that has made women's bodies a crime scene have hurled us to the brink.
There's no woman in South Africa who is unaffected by GBV-F, myself included. I could write a book about my personal experiences because I too know what it means to be brutalised, terrorised and terrified by men.
Plural. Despite this, I have never and I do not support the reinstatement of the death penalty.
The research on capital punishment as a deterrent to crime, conducted in countries (or states in the United States of America) where it is utilised, is clear - it does not work.
Numerous studies indicate that capital punishment does not deter crime any more effectively than long-term or life imprisonment.
A country as structurally unequal as South Africa should never reinstate the death penalty because just as those on its receiving end during apartheid were Black men, those on its receiving end today will be the poor, who are overwhelmingly Black. Between 1911 and 1995, a total of 4288 people were legally executed in South Africa.
Findings by the Truth and Reconciliation Commission (TRC) found that roughly 95% of those who received and faced the death penalty were Black.
This reflects severe racial imbalances in the legal and capital punishment systems - imbalances that have not fundamentally changed in the democratic dispensation.
In the United States, 52 years after the Civil Rights Act that outlawed discrimination and banned segregation was passed, the death penalty continues to disproportionately affect racial minorities, low-income defendants, and individuals who cannot afford high-quality legal representation.
Furthermore, hundreds of individuals who had been convicted and put on death row are increasingly being exonerated through new evidence or DNA testing. The Innocence Project and other organisations fighting wrongful convictions are overwhelmed with cases.
Data compiled across documented death row exonerations points to several recurring systemic failures: official misconduct, perjury or false accusations, flawed forensics and inadequate defence.
Police or prosecutorial misconduct is present in roughly 71% of wrongful death penalty cases; false testimony or false accusations occur in about 65.5% of cases; misleading or discredited forensic evidence contributes to over 30% of these wrongful convictions; and substandard or ineffective legal representation is a factor in roughly 26% of cases.
This is happening in the wealthiest country in the world, where forensic infrastructure is far more advanced. In South Africa, SAPS labs suffer from broken equipment, expired supply contracts, and staff shortages.
We’re facing a severe forensic crisis, with a DNA testing backlog of over 170 000 cases inside police laboratories. The impact of this on the criminal justice system is incalculable.
While it means potential criminals are walking free, it also means we do not know if we have innocent people in our overcrowded and underfunded prisons.
The irreversibility of capital punishment in a country where the criminal justice system is so fundamentally broken should give us pause.
The structural conditions under which we are calling for the reinstatement of the death penalty should compel greater collective reflection from us.
South Africa's history, which bleeds into its present, doesn't allow us to be casual about calling for the state to legally kill people when those people have historically been Black and poor. We constantly bear witness to how the wealthy evade justice because of their access to resources.
We know that statistically, those with greater access to resources are White. Data from Statistics SA and other agencies tells us that White workers earn a median of about R25 000 per month, while Black African workers earn a median of about R5 200 per month.
Unemployment also affects Black people at a much higher rate than Whites, with rates of 37.6% and 7.9%, respectively. A country that still looks like this is not a country that can ensure fairness in the dispensing of justice and by extension, in fair executions.
We have a legitimate reason to be outraged by the murders being reported in Gauteng and all across the country. It is debilitating. It is scary for all women and that includes me.
But I stand firmly in support of S v Makwanyane, the ruling of the Constitutional Court that brought the death penalty to an end. It was a just and necessary ruling in April 1995 when it was delivered and it remains a just and necessary ruling in September 2026.
Malaika is a Geographer and researcher pursuing a PhD in Geography at the University of Bayreuth in Germany
Never miss a major story. Get breaking news and the latest developments from South Africa and beyond as they happen.