Durban and Soweto are burning – literally. Throughout yesterday (8 October 2026), anti-immigration protests in Durban and Soweto turned violent, with 24 vehicles torched, shops vandalised and looted, and several individuals left injured.
Protestors blocked roads, pelted shops with stones, and forced the closure of foreign-owned businesses, resulting in police deploying stun grenades, cordoning off volatile areas and using Casper vehicles to disperse the crowds and protect foreign nationals who were on the crosshairs of the protestors.
This new wave of violence has its roots in a July 2026 Constitutional Court ruling that struck down provisions of the Refugees Act that barred people from applying for asylum i
f they entered the country irregularly or failed to report to a Refugee Reception Office within five days. Following a Department of Home Affairs directive to comply with the judgment issued on 28 September 2026, hundreds of foreign nationals queued outside offices like the Umbilo/Durban Refugee Reception Centre.
In a South Africa that is already volatile and where anti-immigrant sentiments have been festering for some time, this directive sparked tensions and gave ammunition to organisations like March and March, which spread false claims that the ruling amounted to an "invasion" or an automatic mass-granting of rights. But these claims have no basis in fact.
The Constitutional Court ruling does not make unlawful migration legal or grant automatic status to asylum seekers. It simply requires the Department of Home Affairs to give them an opportunity to submit an application so that their individual claims can be evaluated on merit. Fraudulent, abusive, or unfounded applications are still subject to rejection through standard legal processes.
The ruling is in alignment with the Refugee Convention (and subsequent 1967 Protocol) of which South Africa is a signatory. The Convention is the primary international legal document that defines who a refugee is, sets out their fundamental rights, and outlines the legal obligations of states to protect them.
It entered into force in April 1954 and is supervised by the United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees (UNHCR).
It has three core principles, with the second one being especially relevant to the Constitutional Court ruling. But before I elaborate on this, it is important to make a distinction between an asylum seeker and a refugee.
An asylum seeker is a person who has fled their home country and asked for protection in another country but has not yet received a legal decision on their application. A refugee is an asylum seeker whose claim has been officially processed and recognised under international or domestic law as having a well-founded fear of persecution, war, or violence. The persecution must be founded on race, religion, nationality, political opinion or an alliance with a particular social group.
The first principle of the Refugee Convention, contained in Article 3, pertains to non-discrimination of refugees. It requires that states apply the Convention's provisions without discrimination as to race, religion, or country of origin. The second, contained in Article 31, requires that states should not penalise asylum seekers who enter or are present in their territory without authorisation, provided that they present themselves to authorities without delay.
And the third, contained in Article 33, forbids states from expelling or returning an asylum seeker to a territory where their life or freedom would be threatened. A total of 149 member states of the United Nations have formally acceded to, ratified, or succeeded to the Refugee Convention, while 44 are not party to the Convention.
Of significance is that even countries that are not formal signatories are still bound by the core customary international law principle of non-refoulement, which prohibits returning asylum seekers to a territory where they face threats to their life or freedom.
Over the past few years, and with the rise of right-wing governments in regions like the European Union (EU), which applies the Common European Asylum System, stricter immigration laws have been enforced. Updated EU laws have introduced safe third country rules.
These updated laws came into effect just four months ago.
Per these laws, EU member states can reject asylum applications as inadmissible and transfer applicants to a third country, even if the applicant has no prior connection to that country, provided it is deemed safe and capable of offering protection.
This updated rule, however, excludes unaccompanied minors. Individuals whose asylum claims are denied or who lack a right to stay can be ordered to leave, detained, or transferred to external processing/return hubs outside EU borders, including in countries such as Bangladesh, Colombia, Egypt, India, Kosovo, Morocco, and Tunisia.
Some countries within the EU, such as Poland and Hungary, have implemented much stricter rules anchored on border turnback policies, legal blocks, and restrictive resistance toward processing asylum seekers from outside Europe. This has been widely condemned by European courts, rights groups and other European governments.
I provide this background to demonstrate that the ruling by the Constitutional Court in South Africa is grounded in international legal principle and practice.
It is not an attempt by the Court to facilitate an “invasion” of South Africa, as March and March and other anti-immigrant groups and individuals have claimed. But this should have been explained by the government even before the Constitutional Court made its ruling. This would have prevented or at the very least, minimised the misinformation that has now found root and will be difficult to resolve because March and March has already cemented its narrative.
The government has been forced into a reactive posture, compelled to correct misunderstandings and misinterpretations in an environment that has already been contaminated by misinformation and even disinformation.
The government should have known what the Constitutional Court ruling would do in a country that, just four months ago, was confronted with a terrifying possibility of the repeat of the 2008 violence that claimed tens of lives and led to the displacement of thousands of foreign nationals.
It knew that immigration has become the most sensitive topic in South Africa – one that has the potential to plunge the country into something resembling civil war.
But rather than be proactive in its communications, it waited until violence erupted and only then did the Minister of Justice and Constitutional Development attempt to provide an explanation of the ruling. The Department of Home Affairs has since withdrawn the directive, issuing a statement this morning stating that its decision is based on unforeseen consequences that resulted from it.
The department argues that Refugee Reception Offices (RROs) operations were overwhelmed within days of the directive being issued, and that “Home Affairs officials were placed at risk, and that serious threats to public safety and order had emerged”. It is now embarking on a fresh process to determine a more sustainable approach.
This should not have happened.
The government should have done an assessment before issuing the directive to determine what resources would be required by RROs and the relevant departments, including Justice and Constitutional Development as well as the Presidency. This is work that the government has the capacity to do, and an assessment it should have done prior to issuing the directive, especially knowing the volatility in which we are operating as a country.
What this situation boils down to is poor leadership across the board. It was poor leadership by the Department of Justice and Constitutional Development and the Presidency not to get ahead of the story when the Constitutional Court made its ruling by instituting a knowledge/information dissemination campaign to quell anxieties about what the ruling means and the international legal framework that guides it.
The Government Communications and Information System (GCIS), which is a unit in the Office of the President falling under the political authority of the Minister in the Presidency, has an obligation to provide timely, accurate and accessible information to South Africans. This is a constitutional mandate as prescribed in Section 195(g) of the Constitution. Instead of timely communication at the time of the ruling, it waited until the violence had erupted to issue a statement.
It was poor leadership by the Department of Home Affairs to issue a directive without an assessment and audit of its resources, needs and capacity. Because of this poor leadership, we are in the midst of yet another violent wage of anti-immigration protests that are tearing the country asunder. And because of this poor leadership, we are negotiating anxieties and fears about which city is going to burn next.
Malaika is a researcher and geographer. She is a PhD in Geography candidate at the University of Bayreuth.
Never miss a major story. Get breaking news and the latest developments from South Africa and beyond as they happen.