The Constitutional Court must weigh the rule of law against the interest of justice in the case of disgraced Dr Nandipha Magudumana in her deportation case.
Magudumana escalated her bid for freedom to the apex court, where she is challenging the lawfulness of her arrest in Tanzania.
Magudumana and convicted killer and rapist Thabo Bester were arrested in the East African country in April 2023 while on the run.
But she is arguing that South African authorities flouted the law when they arrested her.
ALSO READ:
Magudumana deportation: ConCourt questions double delegation to Tanzania
Magudumana’s lawyers argue SA authorities undermined law with her deportation
Magudumana’s bid for freedom in ConCourt stalls main trial involving Bester
The Department of Home Affairs has told the Constitutional Court that it was Tanzanian officials who arrested Magudumana and Bester, and it was their decision to hand them over to South African authorities as a form of deportation.
This is in response to the argument by Magudumana’s lawyers that a delegation of South African police and Home Affairs officials unlawfully effected her arrest and disguised extradition in Tanzania.
The court wants to know from Magudumana's lawyer, Anton Kats, how it should approach relief for her if it were to rule in her favour.
"When the government, in the way that it has acted in this case, requires a declaration that the courts of this country will not lend itself to a process in which the person appearing before it was brought before it in the way that is (unlawful)," said Kats.
Ultimately, Magudumana wants the apex court to declare her deportation from Tanzania and subsequent prosecution in South Africa unlawful and, therefore, her release.