Lawyers for disgraced doctor Nandipha Magudumana have argued that South African authorities behaved in a fashion that undermines the rule of law when they deported her from Tanzania.
Magudumana is appealing a Supreme Court of Appeal (SCA) judgement on the lawfulness of her arrest in Tanzania in April 2023.
She was arrested while on the run with convicted criminal and prison escapee Thabo Bester.
ALSO READ:
Legality of Magudumana’s extradition to take centre stage in ConCourt
Magudumana's lawyers to approach ConCourt over plea delays
Magudumana’s bid for freedom in ConCourt stalls main trial involving Bester
At the heart Magudumana’s challenge in the Constitutional Court is whether she and Bester were arrested by South African police in Tanzania, which her lawyers have argued would be illegal.
South African authorities argue that they were in Tanzania to identify the pair, and police were only there because Bester is a dangerous criminal.
But Magudumana’s lawyer, Anton Katz, has disputed this.
“The police have no business at all in playing any role beyond the borders of South Africa. They have no power to do so. South African law is clear, it’s territorial, unless there’s a provision in a statute or in some international idea of extraterritorial power.”
Pointing out the presence of police and Home Affairs officials in Arusha, where Magudumana and Bester were handed over, Katz argued that the State’s conduct was unlawful from start to finish.