The legality of disgraced doctor Nandipha Magudumana’s extradition will take centre stage in the Constitutional Court on Thursday.

Magudumana is challenging how she was brought from Tanzania back to South Africa with her lover and accomplice, Thabo Bester.

The pair was arrested while on the run in Arusha in April 2023 after Bester’s escape from the Manguang Private Security Prison in May 2022.

ALSO READ:

Magudumana's lawyers to approach ConCourt over plea delays

Magudumana’s bid for freedom in ConCourt stalls main trial involving Bester

Magudumana escalates her fight for freedom to ConCourt

When Magudumana took her extradition battle to the Supreme Court of Appeal (SCA) in 2025, the court dismissed her application, ruling that she failed to show that police acted unlawfully.

The court also accepted the version by South African authorities that she was not arrested by the South African Police Service (SAPS) in Tanzania, but by the Tanzanian authorities for violating immigration laws.

The SCA added that SAPS only arrested the pair in South Africa when they landed.

However, there was a dissenting view from SCA Justice Tati Moffat Makgoka, who took issue with the process of handing over Magudumana from Tanzanian police to South African authorities, which Home Affairs claims was due to an agreement between the two countries.

Makgoka ruled that there is no international law procedure that stipulates a fugitive can simply be handed over, adding that the agreement between the two countries was unlawful.

It is on this basis that Magudumana is approaching the Constitutional Court to have her arrest declared unlawful.