The Constitutional Court is unconvinced by the reasons provided by South African authorities for using two delegations in Tanzania to deport disgraced doctor Nandipha Magudumana.

Magudumana has escalated a quest for freedom to the apex court.

She is challenging the legality of her deportation from Tanzania, where she was arrested while on the run with convicted murderer and rapist Thabo Bester in April 2023.

ALSO READ:

Magudumana’s lawyers argue SA authorities undermined law with her deportation

Legality of Magudumana’s extradition to take centre stage in ConCourt

Magudumana's lawyers to approach ConCourt over plea delays

Magudumana’s bid for freedom in ConCourt stalls main trial involving Bester

The question of why South Africa needed to send two delegations to Arusha to escort Thabo Bester and Nandipha Magudumana was a recurring theme in the Constitutional Court on Thursday.

Magudumana's lawyers have agued that her deportation was in fact an extradition in disguise and thus unlawful.

Justice Steven Majiedt questioned the state’s lawyer, Niel Stellenberg, on this.

"Well, it seems to me that what had happened here was that SAPS went there to arrest, this is my impression of all of this and when it turned out that the Tanzanian government is expecting extradition papers, people then turned around and said this is a deportation and it's actually a disguised extradition and SAPS was complicit. That is what it looks like on the papers."

Chief Justice Mandisa Maya also pressed Stellenberg on this question.

The court must establish whether Magudumana’s deportation was lawful and if she can still be prosecuted in South Africa.