The Johannesburg High Court has reserved judgment in a contentious legal battle over the detention of 33 undocumented foreign nationals at the Lindela Repatriation Centre.
The case centres on whether foreign nationals arrested for immigration offences should be detained after expressing an intention to seek asylum or whether refugee protections should kick in at that point.
ALSO READ:
Forced removal of undocumented immigrants from clinics
TMPD arrests 18 undocumented migrants
Controversial judgment over detention of undocumented asylum seekers spotlighted
On Wednesday, judges will visit Lindela to assess conditions and procedures at the facility first-hand.
The United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees (UNHCR) said South Africa cannot penalise asylum seekers for entering the country irregularly, even if they only express an intention to seek asylum after their arrest.
Advocate Nick Ferreira, arguing for the agency, said that Article 31 of the 1951 UN Refugee Convention is not limited to those who seek asylum at ports of entry.
"Article 31 does not only apply in the ideal circumstance when someone presents themselves at a port of entry and immediately seeks asylum. Article 31 arose expressly to deal with the issue of people entering irregularly."
However, the National Prosecuting Authority (NPA) has warned against what it sees as an abuse of the asylum system. Its counsel, William Mokhare, described the situation as a game of "catch me if you can".
"We're dealing with catch me if you can. If you catch me, I apply for asylum."
The NPA argues that authorities must help detainees access the asylum system, but that this does not automatically entitle them to release. It also says the 48-hour detention limit and requirement for magistrate authorisation must be observed.
Judge Lebogang Modiba, however, questioned the UNHCR about its interpretation of Article 31 of the 1951 UN Refugee Convention.
"How can we interpret those provisions to say that process must stop? On the say-so of a person who entered the country, sojourned for years, for months without papers..."
Never miss a major story. Get breaking news and the latest developments from South Africa and beyond as they happen.