The legal battle over the detention of undocumented asylum seekers has put a controversial judgment under the spotlight, with applicants warning that it could undermine protections guaranteed under refugee law.
On Monday, a lawyer representing five foreign nationals who entered South Africa illegally took direct aim at Judge Mandlenkosi Motha's ruling, which allows asylum applications to be processed while applicants remain in detention.
ALSO READ:
Joburg High Court hears landmark battle over detention of asylum seekers
High Court battle tests legality of detaining undocumented asylum seekers
Court to weigh on detention of undocumented migrants wanting to apply for asylum in SA
The lawyer argues that this approach resurrects legal principles that have already been overturned by other courts, insisting that once someone expresses an intention to seek asylum, the Refugee Act must take precedence, regardless of how they entered the country or whether they have been convicted under the Immigration Act.
The five applicants, four Ethiopian nationals and one from the Democratic Republic of Congo (DRC), had already served sentences for illegal entry before being transferred to the Lindela Repatriation Centre.
Their lawyer, Ntshuxeko Chauke, said they repeatedly expressed an intention to seek asylum but were never assisted when they entered the country.
However, it remains unclear to whom they declared this intention, given that they entered the country illegally and outside official ports of entry.
Chauke argued that Judge Motha's ruling effectively resurrects a legal approach that should have been laid to rest.
"We take serious exception to the approach that was taken in the Motaji judgment on the basis that the Motaji judgment appears to bring back or represent what was decided in the Ashebo case. That was decided in Scalabrini."
Another counsel, Thato Madubanya, who represents four Ethiopians who also entered the country illegally, said once they raise the asylum defence, they are de facto refugees.
“The Refugee Act must apply to that person, and they must be labelled as a de facto refugee. We are saying continued detention subsequent to a person making an intention to apply for asylum is because there’s no other legislation that justifies that.”
QUESTIONS OVER AUTOMATIC RELEASE
A full bench of the Johannesburg High Court has questioned whether undocumented foreign nationals should be released automatically the moment they express an intention to seek asylum.
The judges challenged the arguments brought by applicants in the three-day asylum case in the Johannesburg High Court that detention must end immediately.
They raised concerns about potential abuse of the asylum process, as well as the State's ability to trace released applicants and South Africa's international obligations.
They also questioned whether a mere expression of intent, without supporting information about an applicant's circumstances, is enough to secure immediate release.
But the most significant exchange centred on South Africa's obligations under the United Nations Refugee Convention, raised by Judge Lebogang Modiba.
"There's no outright prohibition on the detention of asylum seekers in terms of the convention."
Judge President Aubrey Ledwaba also raised practical concerns about releasing people who may have no fixed addresses.
"Where will they be residing? Because surely these people would not be having addresses, or some of them may not be having addresses."
The hearing continues.
Never miss a major story. Get breaking news and the latest developments from South Africa and beyond as they happen.