A landmark legal battle over the detention of undocumented asylum seekers has been playing out before the Johannesburg High Court this afternoon.

A full bench is hearing 33 matters that will test the implications of a recent Constitutional Court judgment.

ALSO READ:

High Court battle tests legality of detaining undocumented asylum seekers

Court to weigh on detention of undocumented migrants wanting to apply for asylum in SA

Over 400 asylum applications submitted before directive was withdrawn, says Schreiber

At the centre is whether Home Affairs can continue detaining foreign nationals, even after they have declared an intention to seek asylum.

Two Cameroonian nationals, who were arrested in September and later released, are among those challenging the matter.

Lawyer for the two Cameroonian nationals, Advocate Anton Katz, argued that the moment a person expresses an intention to seek asylum, their continued detention under section 34 (1) of the immigration act becomes unlawful.

He said that the section provides for detention pending deportation and cannot be used to keep someone in custody once they have indicated that they want to seek refugee protection.

Katz said there is no lawful basis to arrest an illegal foreigner with this intention in our laws.

“The moment a person exhibits an intention, at that moment he should be free. The lunch comes in, he doesn't like the lunch, he says I want to apply for asylum, his detention becomes unlawful in the true sense,” said Katz.

But the border management authority, represented by Zwelakhe Mokatsane, disagrees that an intimation automatically triggers release.

His argument is that detention may continue if it is individually justified, authorised for a fixed period and accompanied by steps to facilitate access to the asylum process.

The very argument Home Affairs has made.

“An intimation does not by itself require release; any detention must be individually justified,” said Mokatsane.

He also said that the recent con-court judgement has changed the role of the section 23 asylum transit visa.

Meaning that undocumented foreign nationals can still seek asylum, even if they entered the country illegally or have exceeded the five-day period previously required to declare their intention.

Never miss a major story. Get breaking news and the latest developments from South Africa and beyond as they happen.