The Western Cape High Court has dismissed applications by the EFF and African Legal Professionals Association to overturn a decision by Parliament’s Impeachment Committee to cancel its recommendation of advocate Thandazani Madonsela to serve as evidence leader of the Section 89 inquiry.

Handing down the ruling on Friday, Judge Chantel Fortuin said the full bench was divided in its opinion, but that the majority judgment had dismissed both applications.

The EFF had argued that the committee had acted in bad faith when it rescinded the decision to recommend Madonsela for appointment to lead evidence in the misconduct inquiry against President Cyril Ramaphosa in connection with the theft of US dollars from his farm, Phala Phala.

In brief proceedings to hand down the order, Judge Fortuin noted that there were two judgments in this matter.

"The dissenting judgment concludes that it would have reviewed and set aside the committee’s decision to rescind the recommendation with costs."

But she said the majority judgment had dismissed both applications.

Fortuin said the full judgments with reasons for the decisions would be circulated to the parties involved.

ALSO READ:

Parliament defends decision to drop Madonsela as Phala Phala evidence leader

Impeachment Committee dismisses suggestion Ramaphosa has veto over its decision-making

Gana denies bad faith as Impeachment Committee defends U-turn on evidence leader

When the case was heard a month ago, the EFF and ALPA had argued that the impeachment committee had acted in bad faith when it backtracked on the recommendation of Madonsela for the role of evidence leader.

For its part the committee had argued that it was unaware that when Madonsela disclosed that he had provided legal advice to a parliamentary study group on the impeachment matter - that he was referring to the ANC.

It said this situation could be perceived as a conflict of interest, and therefore rescinded the decision.

The impeachment committee has not met for over two months since the legal applications were first launched against it.