Parliament’s Impeachment Committee said that dropping Advocate Thandazani Madonsela as its preferred evidence leader for the Section 89 inquiry did not violate his rights.

The inquiry is due to probe allegations against President Cyril Ramaphosa in connection with the theft of US dollars from his Phala Phala farm.

ALSO READ:

Impeachment Committee dismisses suggestion Ramaphosa has veto over its decision-making

Court bid against Impeachment Committee’s evidence leader decision resumes

Gana denies bad faith as Impeachment Committee defends U-turn on evidence leader

EFF: Impeachment Committee acted in bad faith when rescinding Adv Madonsela recommendation

The committee was in the Western Cape High Court on Wednesday defending its decision to cancel the nomination for Madonsela to lead the evidence, arguing that it was presented with new and material facts that prompted it to later backtrack on the decision.

Madonsela offered legal advice to the African National Congress (ANC) on matters related to the impeachment proceedings.

Advocate Kameel Premhid told the court that the process had not yet reached the point of finality to appoint Madonsela, and therefore the committee was within its powers to reconsider its nomination.

“Politicians are known for what they call their minds, all the time. It doesn’t matter that they do that. What matters ultimately is how the debate unfolds, what the resolution taken was, and the reasons that carried the day,” Premhid said.

The committee said that the applicants, the Economic Freedom Fighters (EFF) and the African Legal Professionals Association, are converting a provisional recommendation into an entitlement.

“I’m not saying the committee can act any willy-nilly, and act irrationally. I’m not saying that at all. What I am saying is the reasons in front of you, that can be distilled from the transcripts, demonstrate that rationality, and just because the process followed is one the applicants complain about doesn’t make it irrational,” Premhid added.

Never miss a major story. Get breaking news and the latest developments from South Africa and beyond as they happen.