Should someone who says they've been a victim of sexual assault have to endure questions about their character before the case even goes to trial?
It's a question raised by 702's Bongani Bingwa following testimony in Shadrack Sibiya's bail hearing.
Sibiya's defence raised questions about intimate photographs allegedly taken by the teenage accuser.
The suspended top cop is currently behind bars on bail and faces several charges, including rape of an 18-year-old.
He claims the sexual encounter was consensual.
ALSO: Too drunk to consent to sex? Here's what South African law says
The Political Desk: Sibiya Bail Hearing and Victims’ Confidence in Justice
Video · Brightcove player not connected in this prototype
Bingwa put his question to advocate Nthabiseng Dubazana, managing director of Dubazana Attorneys, asking whether focusing on the girl's behaviour risked shaming her rather than dealing with the allegations against the accused.
Dubazana said it was important to remember that the standard of proof for these charges is extremely high.
It has to be beyond a reasonable doubt that this person has committed this alleged crime.
She said defence lawyers had a duty to challenge the state's evidence and that an accused person was entitled to a fair hearing.
"It is not the defence's job to make the state's life easy."
But she did question whether Sibiya's lawyers were going too far during a bail application.
"They are conducting a bail application as if it was a trial," she said.
The purpose of a the bail hearing was to determine whether exceptional circumstances existed to justify releasing the Sibiya on bail.
"They are supposed to prove that there are exceptional circumstances that exist for their client to be considered as a suitable candidate for bail. Why are we going into the merits of the case?" said Dubazana
She also warned that talking about evidence in detail while investigations were still underway could also create problems for the defence when the actual trial begins.
Never miss a major story. Get breaking news and the latest developments from South Africa and beyond as they happen.