Two cases making headlines locally and internationally recently have shone a spotlight on the issue of intoxication and consent.
In South Africa, suspended top cop Shadrack Sibiya is behind bars and faces charges including rape of an 18-year-old.
He claims the sexual encounter was consensual, but testimony suggests the young woman was "pretty much comatose" as a result of being intoxicated.
Meanwhile, in the US, a group of former Cornell University students stand accused of raping an intoxicated woman.
'Jane Doe' says she was drugged and raped by the men in 2024 at the New York State University.
That case has raised questions about sexual assault laws in several US states.
In New York, someone who voluntarily drinks alcohol or takes drugs is not automatically regarded as incapable of consenting to sex, even if they become very drunk.
The laws have sparked widespread criticism and been dubbed the “voluntary intoxication loophole” by US media.
So, here in South Africa, if someone voluntarily gets drunk, does that mean they can still consent to sex?
And what happens if they were so intoxicated that they barely knew what was happening?
ALSO READ:
'Believed consent' can no longer be used as a defence, rules court
Understanding the High Court ruling on rape and consent
Drunk women cannot consent, but does the law and society understand this?
Video · Brightcove player not connected in this prototype
Speaking to CapeTalk's John Maytham, Fatima Shaik, executive director of People Opposing Women Abuse (POWA), said the US legislators urgently need to close that loophole.
"A woman consenting to drinking is drinking and not consenting to sex. So the consent was to drink and to maybe even snort ketamine, but nowhere did she consent to having sex or allegedly consent to having sex."
And she explained that South African law was clear about the principle of consent.
"When a woman consents to drinking, that doesn't simply give a person the right to then rape the person because they are in your midst."
Under South Africa's Criminal Law (Sexual Offences and Related Matters) Amendment Act, consent means voluntary or uncoerced agreement.
Shaik said the legislation specifically deals with circumstances where someone is incapable in law of appreciating the nature of the sexual act.
"Including being in an altered state of consciousness because of either having alcohol or drugs or any form of medication or substances that, to the extent that consciousness or judgment is adversely affected."
Speaking directly to the alleged events in the Sibyia case, Shaik said someone who had passed out would not be in a position to give consent.
"If the person had passed out, they were not in any clear position to give consent. And that is clear. And I mean, even if she did get up from, you know, being comatose, I still think that she's in no position to give consent."
Never miss a major story. Get breaking news and the latest developments from South Africa and beyond as they happen.