President Cyril Ramaphosa says that an argument made by opposition parties that South Africans have a right to know about the burglary at his Phala Phala farm is a populist slogan which has no bearing on his legal challenge against a report that has led to his impeachment.
His legal counsel Wim Trengove told the Western Cape High Court on Friday that institutions which investigated the possession of the $580, 000 ostensibly raised through a sale of buffalo had all exonerated him of wrongdoing.
Ramaphosa was before the court this week in a bid to overturn a parliamentary report that suggested he has a case to answer for in respect of his conduct following the theft of that money, stashed in a couch, more than six years ago.
In closing arguments before the court on Friday, Advocate Wim Trengove said several agencies, including the Public Protector, the SA Reserve Bank and the SA Revenue Service as well as Parliament’s Joint Standing Committee on Intelligence and the National Prosecuting Authority had all cleared President Cyril Ramaphosa of any legal breaches.
ALSO READ:
Ramaphosa can’t claim ‘reputational harm’ to avoid impeachment proceedings: Opposition parties
Phala Phala saga: Opposition parties claim Ramaphosa hid $580k farm theft
Search for Ramaphosa’s stolen US Dollars in Namibia spotlighted in WC High Court
"So to suggest this inquiry, this case, is the first inquiry into the question or event and therefore should be a full inquiry of all its aspects, is with respect, unfounded," said Trengove.
Trengove further countered arguments from opposition parties that the courts should not interfere in an ongoing Parliamentary process, saying it would not make sense for Ramaphosa to only challenge any unfairness, once it has been concluded.
"Are they suggesting that the President should wait until after he’s been impeached and then take the report on review? That’s an absurdity to suggest an impeached president can litigate his way back into office," said Trengove.
Judgment in the matter has been reserved.