The Johannesburg High Court on Friday heard that the defence in the murder trial of four-year-old Nada Jane Challita may have obtained some of its evidence illegally.

The father of the slain child, Elie Challita, took the stand for cross-examination as part of the continuation of sentencing proceedings.

ALSO READ:

'You made sure I live with the fact that my child drowned': Nada-Jane’s father confronts killer in court

EXCLUSIVE | Nada-Jane Challita's parents reflect on her untimely passing 3 years on

[WATCH] Amber Lee Hughes admits to drowning 4-year-old Nada-Jane Challita

Key events in the Amber Lee Hughes case – From arrest to guilty verdict in murder of Nada-Jane

The court heard that Amber Lee Hughes, who was found guilty of the murder and rape of her former partner’s child, had allegedly given her defence team parts of a Children's Court record regarding Nada Jane's custody case.

Objecting to the line of questioning, prosecutor Rolene Barnard raised concerns about how the evidence was obtained and whether there was a court order to access such sensitive information.

“I will refer the court to Section 66 of the Children's Act. We cannot have access to that file. We cannot place this evidence before this court. I do not know what is in that file because it is privileged. It is confidential. That file, and whatever is in that file, can only be accessed through a proper court order.”

Presiding Judge Richard Mkhabela admonished the defence, stating they had obtained the sensitive files not from the biological parents, but from the accused, who is not related to the child.

“There was no court order entitling the accused to do that. The accused is not even a biological parent, mother, or father of that child. So you have been given a record, not by the biological mother, not by the biological father, without a prior court order. And you are using the contents to test the credibility of this witness.

“And you didn't disclose it to the State. You’re a seasoned practitioner. Are you not ambushing the State, apart from the legality?”

Never miss a major story. Get breaking news and the latest developments from South Africa and beyond as they happen.