In emotionally charged sentencing proceedings at the Johannesburg High Court, the father of slain four-year-old Nada Jane Challita shared a letter with his child’s killer.

Taking the stand to submit evidence, Elie Challita told the court how much Amber Lee Hughes’ actions have scarred his family.

ALSO READ:

EXCLUSIVE | Nada-Jane Challita's parents reflect on her untimely passing 3 years on

[WATCH] Amber Lee Hughes admits to drowning 4-year-old Nada-Jane Challita

Key events in the Amber Lee Hughes case – From arrest to guilty verdict in murder of Nada-Jane

On 23 January 2023, just hours after Challita had left his daughter in Hughes’ care while travelling for work, Hughes drowned and raped the 4-year-old during heated arguments with her father over text messages.

During her submission of evidence earlier this year, Hughes said she had decided to kill the little girl as a means of saving her, claiming that living with her father would leave her in unforeseen circumstances.

Hughes also submitted that she was the one who took care of the child, claiming that Nada Jane Challita was allegedly unkempt and neglected by her father.

As Elie Challita made his way to the witness stand in Courtroom 2D on Thursday, he glanced at Hughes, whose head remained downcast for most of the proceedings.

In the gallery, directly behind Hughes, her father sat where he is usually positioned during court appearances. Meanwhile, the mother of the slain child, Amy Johnston, was at times comforted by her mother as she cried.

Challita was granted permission to read his letter to the court. Before doing so, he first read a message written by Hughes three months before she killed Nada Jane Challita.

In the two pages he read, Hughes apologised for many of the things that had happened during their relationship.

“This is a message sent to me by the accused, Elie, the man whom I will always believe is my true soulmate. The man who was always there for me when I hurt him. The man who has done nothing but make me happy. The man who included me in everything. The man who trusted me with his life. The man who put everyone before himself. The man who always made me feel pretty. The man I will regret pushing away for the rest of my life.

“I don't deserve any more of your time. I have everything to be sorry about. I'm sorry for taking from you when all you ever did was give. I'm sorry for taking advantage of your kindness when all you ever did was try and make me feel safe. I'm sorry for making you feel like you weren't good enough. When I messaged those guys, I'm sorry. I damaged you and your things when all you ever did was buy me things and spoil me. I'm sorry for making you feel unsafe around me when all you ever did was protect me. I'm sorry for coming back time and time again when all you ever did was crave peace,” Challita read.

‘She will never not be a part of our lives’ – Nada-Jane’s parents, three years after her murder

Video · Brightcove player not connected in this prototype

After finishing Hughes’ message, he went on to read his own note, one that articulated what he has been feeling for the past three years since his daughter was killed.

He also expressed how the constant postponements in the matter have affected him.

“On that day, Amber Hughes, I begged you. I said I loved you. I apologised to you. I did everything you asked, just so you don't hurt her, but you ignored it all. You did pack a bag to take her. I saw the bag you packed, but that wasn't going to hurt me enough, no? It can't be permanent.

“Amber Hughes, you were very interested in my sea rescue mission stories. You asked for details. You asked me to rate death by drowning, and I said it's the worst and slow torture next to being burnt alive. I never knew you were going to use it against my baby girl, who loved the water like me. Nada Jane, the shining soul that gave you nothing but love and trust,” he shared.

“Amber Hughes, after you threatened to kill her, you spent weeks apologising and begging and explaining yourself, and crying on all the occasions, and promising that you would never hurt her, while she was just a tool. Just a tool against me, as she was a tool to get me.

“You made sure I live with the fact that my child drowned and I couldn't save her. And she got raped on top of the most horrible death, and I couldn't save her. You did that in order to destroy me. You tortured and violated a four-year-old girl to death to destroy me.

“And yes, you did. Well done.”

The matter will return to the Johannesburg High Court on Friday.

Never miss a major story. Get breaking news and the latest developments from South Africa and beyond as they happen.