Parliament’s Impeachment Committee has filed its application for leave to appeal the Western Cape High ruling that has temporarily stalled hearings of the inquiry probing misconduct allegations against President Cyril Ramaphosa.

Rather than lodge a separate appeal, it’s elected to join the application for leave to appeal directly to the Constitutional Court first lodged by the African Transformation Movement (ATM) just days after July’s order handed down by three judges.

ALSO READ:

Impeachment Committee to consider legal opinion on right to compel Ramaphosa to testify

Parliamentary legal opinion suggests that Ramaphosa won’t be able to dodge testifying at impeachment inquiry

ANC accused of delaying tactics for doubting Parly’s legal advice to Impeachment Committee

Acting on behalf of the committee, chairperson Makashule Gana said it was inappropriate for the court to halt a constitutional process intended to hold the president accountable.

In its application to the court, the Impeachment Committee said the impact of the interdict is far-reaching and damaging to the doctrine of the separation of powers as well as accountability by public representatives, including the President.

Gana said such uncertainty should not be allowed to linger.

Last week, Gana said, personally, he did not believe the committee should appeal the High Court ruling.

But he’s nonetheless carried out the resolution of the majority, saying it believes the Constitutional Court has the jurisdiction to consider the appeal since it has a direct bearing on the court’s May judgment that instructed Parliament to establish a Section 89 inquiry.



The committee said that although the interdict is only interim, it believes its appealable because of the irreparable effect that it carries.

Gana has pointed out that the same court found differently when former Public Protector Busisiwe Mkhwebane attempted to stay her impeachment proceedings pending a challenge to its lawfulness.

The committee added that the majority judgment of the High Court on 24 July conflated harm with the irreparable harm it said the president would suffer if the proceedings were to continue before the court has been able to review the lawfulness of report that has led to the inquiry.

Finally, the committee said both the majority and minority judgments were incorrect in believing they had the jurisdiction to interdict the May Constitutional Court order.

Never miss a major story. Get breaking news and the latest developments from South Africa and beyond as they happen.