Parliament’s Impeachment Committee will on Wednesday be considering a legal opinion on the committee’s right to compel the president to testify in his defence on misconduct charges.

It’s been a week since the committee resolved to appeal a High Court ruling that has interdicted it from holding public hearings into the conduct of President Cyril Ramaphosa in connection with events that unfolded on his Phala Phala farm in 2020, when United States (US) Dollars stashed in a couch were stolen.

ALSO READ:

Parliamentary legal opinion suggests that Ramaphosa won’t be able to dodge testifying at impeachment inquiry

ANC accused of delaying tactics for doubting Parly’s legal advice to Impeachment Committee

Impeachment inquiry: Parties throw names into pool of possible evidence leader candidates

The legal opinion circulated to members of Parliament (MPs) in preparation for Wednesday’s meeting suggests that Ramaphosa can’t invoke the criminal law principle to remain silent in a parliamentary setting.

An opinion compiled by Parliament’s legal advisors grapples with four key questions MPs asked them to consider at a previous meeting.

Chief among these is whether the President can be compelled to testify at the Section 89 inquiry.

The opinion suggests the president would not be treated differently from any other witness called to Parliament to give evidence, and that he should be afforded the opportunity to testify voluntarily, failing which he may be summoned to do so.

The committee is further advised against a suggestion that he testify first to assist in determining the scope of the inquiry, noting that the president does not bear a reverse onus to prove his own innocence at the start of proceedings.



Furthermore, the legal opinion has shot down a previous suggestion by some MPs, but abandoned at last week’s meeting, that it can’t call the panel that compiled the impeachment report to brief it.

Ramaphosa has taken that report on judicial review, and Parliament’s legal advisors point out that since their mandate ended when they submitted their findings to Parliament in 2022, they can’t be compelled to do more than that.

As for establishing a standard of proof to test the evidence that will be put before it, the opinion suggests the Impeachment Committee follow the lead of the Section 194 committee, which considered the impeachment of former Public Protector Busisiwe Mkhwebane.

In the absence of Parliamentary rules making provision for this, the committee is advised to ensure that any finding it makes is supported by cogent, reliable and persuasive evidence sufficient to satisfy constitutional requirements of legality, rationality and procedural fairness.

Never miss a major story. Get breaking news and the latest developments from South Africa and beyond as they happen.