The Constitutional Court’s ruling in the Tafelberg case has renewed debate about how Cape Town deals with land use and the legacy of apartheid spatial planning.
The court last week ruled that the 2015 sale of the Tafelberg School site in Sea Point was unlawful and unconstitutional, saying authorities failed in their duty to consider the land for affordable housing.
"The real point about the Tafelberg case was, if you see that land in the Sea Point area, why can we not have low-cost housing in areas which were hitherto exclusively for whites? Effectively what this case is saying is you've got an obligation to deal with the question of spatial geography, which we inherited from apartheid, and that was the central piece of the case," explained Dennis Davis, former Judge President of the Competition Appeal Court.
ConCourt’s Tafelberg ruling exposes spectre of spatial apartheid haunting Cape Town
Video · Brightcove player not connected in this prototype
ALSO READ: Tafelberg site: Concourt finds public consultation treated as 'ticking box' exercise
While the ruling does not prescribe specific outcomes, Davis said it requires more detailed planning and accountability in land decisions.
"Here the question is what are you going to be doing about the fact that our city is so scarred from the apartheid period and how are you going to change that?"
ALSO READ: WC govt has 3 months to submit plans for affordable housing after Tafelberg ruling
The city and province must now report back to court on how they intend to meet their constitutional obligations regarding well-located housing.