More than a decade since the Western Cape provincial government approved the sale of the former Tafelberg school in Sea Point, the Constitutional Court today ruled the transaction to have been unlawful.

Although the sale has since been cancelled, the apex court on Thursday found the province and the City of Cape Town wanting to make adequate provision for affordable housing within the city’s central areas.

ALSO READ:

Future of Tafelberg site under scrutiny as Heritage Western Cape weighs in

ConCourt reserves judgment in Tafelberg school land sale matter

Heritage Western Cape halts proposed redevelopment of Tafelberg site

Over the years, the case has become a landmark matter for social housing activists and the lobby group Ndifuna Ukwazi in challenging the city’s apartheid legacy of spatial segregation.

Granting the applicants leave to appeal a 2024 Supreme Court ruling, the Constitutional Court largely agreed with the Western Cape High Court, which found in 2020 that the provincial government had erred in several respects when it decided to dispose of the school site in 2015.

Handing down the judgment, Justice Nonkosi Mhlanthla said even though the sale was now moot, the court still had a duty to consider the constitutional rights of citizens to housing and access to services.

She said evidence before the court did not suggest that the City of Cape Town had developed affordable housing in well-located central areas, and that distance from the CBD alone was not a suitable determinant.

“The matter is about the full participation in the life of the city, including access to front-facing centres such as the CBD and Sea Point.”

The court said Cape Town remained divided along racial lines with poor, working-class families excluded from amenity-rich areas.



“The city had not implemented any social or affordable housing projects in or near central Cape Town or near economic nodes in a manner that addresses social injustice.”

The province and the city have now been put to terms to submit regular reports to the High Court detailing its plans, projects and progress made to develop affordable housing and to undo the spatial segregation of the city.