The Constitutional Court has found the extent of meaningful public participation in the decision to sell a former school in Cape Town's seaside suburb of Sea Point to have been inadequate.
The Western Cape Provincial government suffered a major blow in the country's highest court over its handling of the 2015 decision to sell the Tafelberg School to the Phyllis Jowell Jewish Day School.
ALSO READ:
ConCourt rules sale of former Tafelberg school site in Sea Point unlawful
Emotional scenes at Sea Point church after historic ConCourt housing victory
The Constitutional Court has gone as far as to order the provincial government to amend its public participation regulations.
Wednesday's victory by the social justice lobby group Ndifuna Ukwazi ends a 10-year court battle to have the sale of the Tafelberg school site declared unlawful.
Although the sale of the Tafelberg school was cancelled in 2020, the Constitutional Court said the matter still has a bearing on spatial redress and public participation in matters of local government.
Handing down judgment on Wednesday, Justice Nonkosi Mhlanthla said the facts in the Tafelberg case show that an inadequate public participation procedure was adopted.
The court noted that the first period of public comment after the decision to sell was taken in November 2015, fell squarely within the Christmas holiday period.
The notice also did not identify the buyer, nor the proposed purchase price of R135 million.
In this matter, the province conducted what amounted to a ticking-box exercise with minimal indication that it was genuinely receptive to the public’s input.
The court said the province’s regulations that public participation only commences after a potential buyer has made an offer are unreasonable and inadequate, and have declared them invalid.
The provincial government has now been given 12 months to amend the regulations linked to the 1998 Western Cape Land Regulation Act, to allow for public participation before a sale agreement is reached.