The Constitutional Court has heard that Judge Sisi Khampepe's role as chairperson of the TRC cases inquiry does not constitute a judicial function and should not enjoy protections that apply to sitting judges.
The court is hearing an urgent application for direct access and leave to appeal a High Court ruling that dismissed a bid to remove Khampepe as chairperson of the inquiry.
ALSO READ: Bid to remove Judge Sisi Khampepe as TRC cases chair continues in ConCourt
ALSO READ: Court dismisses application to remove Khampepe as chair of TRC cases inquiry
Former presidents Jacob Zuma and Thabo Mbeki are seeking to have Khampepe removed, alleging a reasonable apprehension of bias arising from her previous roles on the TRC Amnesty Committee and at the NPA during the 1990s.
Their review application was dismissed by the Johannesburg High Court in March.
The High Court found they had failed to comply with section 47 of the Superior Courts Act, which requires the consent of the head of a court before legal proceedings may be instituted against a judge.
Advocate Dali Mpofu, acting for Zuma, responding to questions by Deputy Chief Justice Dunston Mlambo, argues that section 47 does not apply to Khampepe.
"A judge who is chairing a commission is not performing a judicial function. Absolutely, whether he is retired or not, they are performing a judicial function, and that you will find in Heath, in Heath, they make the specific example that when a judge is chairing a commission, they are certainly not performing an executive function."