The Constitutional Court will on Monday hear an urgent application for direct access and leave to appeal a High Court judgment that dismissed a bid to remove Judge Sisi Khampepe as chairperson of the Truth and Reconciliation Commission (TRC) cases inquiry.
Former presidents Jacob Zuma and Thabo Mbeki's review application was dismissed by the Johannesburg High Court in March.
ALSO READ:
Zuma approaches Constitutional Court in urgent bid to remove Justice Khampepe
Court dismisses application to remove Khampepe as chair of TRC cases inquiry
Zuma’s counsel accuses TRC inquiry chair Khampepe of gross misconduct
The majority judgment found the court lacked jurisdiction to hear the matter because the applicants failed to comply with Section 47 of the Superior Courts Act before instituting legal proceedings against a judge.
Judge Khampepe's legal team, led by now-acting Constitutional Court Judge Tembeka Ngcukaitobi, successfully argued before a full bench of the Johannesburg High Court that the review application was not properly placed before the court.
The majority of the court agreed, finding it lacked jurisdiction to consider the merits of the case.
The court found that Zuma and Mbeki failed to comply with Section 47(1) of the Superior Courts Act, which requires the Chief Justice's consent before civil proceedings may be instituted against a judge.
Before the Constitutional Court, the former presidents are relying heavily on a dissenting judgment by Judge Modiba, who found that Section 47 did not apply in these circumstances and considered the merits of the case.
Modiba concluded that Khampepe's decision not to recuse herself was unlawful because it was taken by her alone, rather than by the three-member commission.
She found that, had the full commission considered the recusal application, it would have granted the relief sought by Zuma and Mbeki.
The two contend that Khampepe should be removed from the commission, arguing that because of her previous roles at the National Prosecuting Authority (NPA) and TRC Amnesty Committee during the 1990s she might be biased against them.