The National Dialogue is facing growing scrutiny over questions of secrecy, spending and governance, with internal disputes threatening to overshadow its national rollout.
Multiple sources have told Eyewitness News that members of the steering committee have been asked to sign a confidentiality agreement, a document seen by Eyewitness News.
ALSO READ:
Chaotic start to National Dialogue as delegates criticise government
Government to utilise own facilities for National Dialogue to cut costs
JUDITH FEBRUARY | The National Dialogue: Ramaphosa's illusion of action
VUKILE DLWATI | A R700m National Dialogue limits the butterfly that SA is dying to become
MANDY WIENER | National Dialogue a missed opportunity on foreigner sentiment
Separately, sources have raised concerns about financial oversight, governance structures, accountability and decision-making within the process.
The concerns come as pilot dialogues are being implemented across the country and have sparked questions about whether the organisation's governance systems are developing at the same pace as its expanding mandate.
OATH OF SECRECY TRIGGERS BACKLASH
The latest flashpoint is a proposed confidentiality agreement presented to members of the National Dialogue steering committee by the National Economic Development and Labour Council (NEDLAC).
The proposal has met resistance from some members, who question why confidentiality requirements are being introduced before key governance, ethics and whistleblower protections have been established.
The document, signed by NEDLAC executive director Makhukhu Mampuru, reads: “In order to protect the integrity of the process, it is essential that appropriate safeguards are in place to protect confidential information, preserve the integrity of deliberative processes, and ensure compliance with applicable governance, legal and ethical obligations, all members of the Steering Committee are required to sign the attached ‘Oath of Secrecy’ document as part of the governance process.
“The ‘Oath of Secrecy’ is intended to support the principles of responsible governance, confidentiality, mutual trust and institutional integrity that are necessary for the effective functioning of the Steering Committee and the National Dialogue as a whole.
As a member of the Steering Committee, you are kindly requested to sign and return the document to the National Dialogue Secretariat by no later than Friday, 12 June 2026. The return email address is: [email protected].”
Critics argue that a process presented as citizen-led and transparent should not impose restrictions that could limit disclosure of information about its internal operations.
For some members, the debate over confidentiality has become a symbol of wider concerns about accountability and oversight.
SECRECY OVER SPENDING
Concerns about secrecy within the National Dialogue extend beyond the controversial confidentiality oath imposed on steering committee members.
There is no transparency about the finances of the steering committee itself, which is administered through NEDLAC and funded directly from South Africa’s national contingency reserves.
National Treasury transferred R107.7 million to NEDLAC during the previous financial year and a further R88.9 million for the current financial year to support the National Dialogue process.
TAXPAYER-FUNDED GRAVY TRAIN LEAVES STATION.
Insiders allege that the inflow of public funds has triggered what they describe as a “feeding frenzy”, with concerns growing that another taxpayer-funded gravy train has left the station.
Despite repeated requests, including from Eyewitness News, there remains limited public information about how the money has been spent.
Insiders said control over the funds is exercised by a group of five people: Qhamisa Tengile, a staunch African National Congress (ANC) member, Dr Valentia Andrews, Queen Rebecca Como, David Morema and Luks Gwexa (Matiso).
They form part of the 12-member management executive for the National Dialogue.
Even with repeated requests for procurement records, budget breakdowns, expenditure reports, meeting minutes and other documentation required for oversight, none have been provided.
“We had two national gatherings of the steering committee, and we found out something like a shuttle ride from the airport to NEDLAC costing, I don't know, R20,000. You know, so when we asked for in-person meetings, they told us it's no more money because they used all of the money to gather us. But, you know, I know what it costs to convene a conference. I know what it costs to fly people and to drive them in from the airport,” said an insider.
Eyewitness News has learnt that some members who joined the process on a voluntary basis have now sought compensation and addressed a letter to the National Treasury.
This is despite it having been made clear that participation in the steering committee is on a voluntary basis.
IS IT A CITIZEN-LED PROCESS?
Sources within the structure argue that a dialogue intended to be driven by ordinary South Africans has become increasingly political, with allegations that provincial coordinators are now placed in the different premiers’ offices.
Some members fear that this is to syphon money from the dialogue to fund a specific political party ahead of the local government elections.
One insider said, “What has just been decided is that all dialogues will be run through the municipalities. So, there's a group of us who's objecting to this because we also know what happens to them in the municipalities. So, the municipalities will provide opinions, will then put out a tender for catering.
“And yeah, so the problem, of course, is that a lot of the route that the National Dialogue is intended to respond to is precisely located at the local government level. Now what is supposed to be a citizen-led process has been taken over by the municipalities and by, which of course is mostly ANC.
”
They said the seeming political influence is beginning to overshadow the broader public participation that the process was intended to encourage.
ELECTION DISPUTE STILL HANGS OVER MANCO
The legitimacy of the current management committee remains under a cloud following a disputed election held in March.
“The structure was basically forced on us in January at UNISA because the organogram was shared with us, and we were like, whoa, we had no say in this whatsoever. This was pre-drafted, and we just had to rubber-stamp it.”
Steering committee members have raised concerns about alleged slate voting, changes to voting procedures, the absence of an accessible voters' roll, nomination processes and ballot reconciliation.
The dispute has resulted in an independent investigation led by former Commission for Conciliation, Mediation and Arbitration (CCMA) director Nerine Khan.
The findings have yet to be made public.
GOVERNANCE CRISIS DEEPENS
While the National Dialogue prepares for its next phase, insiders said basic governance safeguards remain conspicuously absent.
An ethics committee has yet to be established. A whistleblower framework remains outstanding. Conflict-of-interest rules have not been finalised, and a comprehensive governance framework has still not been adopted.
These concerns have been compounded by a series of fractious meetings in recent weeks.
Members said multiple meetings since 7 June have been delayed or thrown into disarray by bitter disputes over governance and representation.
“We had a meeting on Monday evening, which was again derailed as certain members attempted to have 9 others removed before the meeting even started, on the administrative basis that these members, whilst confirmed as appointed members by NEDLAC on the call, simply are awaiting appointment letters from the president. These members were added to the WhatsApp group, invited to all committee and, where relevant, subcommittee meetings, participated in the election process of ManCo on 8 March and, now, are being removed by ManCo who’ve taken this decision of their own accord.”
DISPUTE PROMPTS LEGAL CHALLENGE
The dispute has now escalated to the courts, with the affected members preparing a legal challenge to their removal.
Meanwhile, efforts to establish a governance task team have also stalled.
Members say a meeting intended to finalise the structure descended into chaos after disagreements over its composition, forcing the chairperson to withdraw a ruling and reopen the process.
Weeks later, the task team remains in limbo.
Some members believe the delays are not accidental but part of a broader effort to block stronger governance, oversight, and accountability.
The emergence of multiple insiders raising similar concerns suggests the National Dialogue is grappling with far more than routine administrative challenges.
Questions were sent to the National Dialogue’s spokesperson, Tengile, nearly two weeks ago, but no response has been received.
This article by Eyewitness News has been updated since the original date of publication.