The Economic Freedom Fighters (EFF) in the City of Tshwane has penned a 45-page complaint against the Municipality’s City Manager, Johann Mettler, calling for his suspension.
This is the party’s latest and most serious attempt to remove Mettler, having previously publicly voiced its displeasure with his handling of the capital metro affairs.
Ageing water infrastructure deters Tshwane's wish to reduce reliance on tankers
Tshwane city manager reprimands municipal workers who celebrated Brink's ousting
EWN understands the move has caused friction among the governing coalition in Tshwane, with the EFF and African National Congress (ANC) in favour of Mettler's removal, while ActionSA remains undecided.
On Thursday, the Democratic Alliance (DA) plans to hold a media briefing and plot to expose what it calls the ulterior motivations behind the ANC and EFF’s plot to remove Mettler.
EFF’S TSHWANE LEADER GOES AFTER METTLER
The 45-page complaint is penned by EFF’s Tshwane caucus leader, Obakeng Ramabodu, who also
serves as Tshwane MMC for Environmental and Agricultural Management.
Ramabodu accuses Mettler of “serious misconduct, financial misconduct, maladministration and gross dereliction of duty”.
He also demands Mettler be placed on precautionary suspension while these allegations against him are being probed.
ALLEGATION 1: IRREGULAR APPOINTMENT OF FIRE CHIEF
On 31 March 2026, the Public Protector (PP) released a report finding there were irregularities in the appointment of Moshema Mosia to the position of Tshwane’s chief of Emergency Services.
The PP’s report found, among other things, that the position was not properly advertised with the qualification requirements written ambiguously.
The report also found that the Selection Panel also failed to conduct background and reference checks of candidates, as required by legislation.
Mettler, as the chairperson of the Selection Panel, was found particularly culpable by the PP, with the report noting, “he failed to complete the report on the outcome of the screening process before the interviews took place, contrary to Regulation 14(2) of the 2014 Regulation”.
The PP outlines to remedial actions for Mettler as the City Manager; implement controls to ensure future appointments are made in compliance with municipal legislation and qualifications for the role of Chief of Emergency are aligned to Section 5 of the Fire Brigade Act and section 45 of the Disaster Management Act.
In his complaint, Ramabodu describes Mettler’s regarding the matter as tantamount to “maladministration and improper conduct and materially contributed to a flawed, irregular and non-compliant recruitment process.”
Ramabodu said the PP’s binding remedial actions have not been implemented by Mettler, saying the City Manager has committed a breach of his constitutional obligation.
A report on Mosia and the PP’s report will be tabled before a council meeting on Thursday.
ALLEGATION 2: RESIGNATION OF SENIOR MANAGER
Ramabodu, EFF’s charismatic leader in Tshwane, accuses Mettler of overseeing the “irregular” appointment of Ashraf Adam as the municipality’s Governance and Support Officer (GSO).
In January 2025, a confidential report was tabled before the council, alleging that Adam failed to disclose his “mutual separation” from a previous employer in 2011.
Before this non-disclosure could be investigated, Adam resigned from his position.
The EFF in Tshwane said this was another example of Mettler failing in his obligation to conduct adequate oversight over the appointment of senior managers.
ALLEGATION 3, 4 & 5: IRREGULAR APPOINTMENT OF MADLANGA WITNESS TO NON-EXISTENT POST
The Tshwane Municipality has a division called the Asset Protection Security Services (APSS).
APSS is tasked with protecting the municipality’s critical infrastructure.
The division was initially housed under the office of the City Manager; however, in 2024, it was moved to the Tshwane Metro Police Department (TMPD).
In the same year, TMPD hired former Ekurhuleni Metro Police Department (EMPD) Deputy Chief, Revo Spies, to head APSS.
Spies was also given the rank of TMPD Deputy Chief.
Spies has testified at the Madlanga Commission about the corruption he inherited at APSS, with a select few private security companies receiving preferential treatment when it comes to the awarding of contracts.
Ramabodu writes in his complaint letter that Spies’ appointment is invalid since he was appointed to a position that does not exist on TMPD’s approved organisational structure.
Yolande Faro, TMPD Chief, testified before the Madlanga Commission that the position had to be created after APSS was moved to the metro police department.
The EFF also accused Spies of not declaring to the municipality an adverse investigation against him from his previous employer, the EMPD.
Spies was suspended from the EMPD on allegations that he acted without authorisation when he extended the contract of Syntell, a tech company that administers traffic fines for the metro.
However, Spies took the EMPD to the Labour Court and was exonerated.
The ruling found Spies didn’t act alone, as the extension was granted by Ekurhuleni Municipality’s City Manager.
The EFF also makes allegations that Spies was not qualified for the position he was hired for. The EFF said the allegations against Spies were raised by Tshukudu Malatji, Director of APSS.
In the complaint letter, Malatji is referred to as a “whistleblower” by the red berets.
They accuse Mettler of victimising Malatji.
Malatji also testified at the Madlanga Commission, where he admitted to having a frosty
working relationship with Spies.
Malatji was also caught several times in a lie during his testimony at the commission. He also admitted to signing off on invoices without verifying services had been rendered.
ALLEGATION 6: SUPPRESSING OF ROOIWAL SIU REPORT
In September 2023, President Cyril Ramaphosa signed a proclamation allowing the Special Investigating Unit (SIU) to probe the failed R295 million upgrade to the Rooiwal Waste Water Treatment Plant.
In 2019, the Tshwane Municipality awarded a contract to a consortium headed up by controversial businessman Edwin Sodi for the upgrading of Rooiwal.
However, the consortium later abandoned the site, leaving much of the work it was contracted for unfinished.
The EFF in Tshwane alleges the SIU has completed phase one of its report into the Rooiwal tender; however, that report has not been tabled before the council.
“Mr Mettler failed to table the SIU’s findings formally before Council, depriving Council of critical information required for the exercise of its constitutional oversight function,” reads the complaint letter.
The red berets have also accused Mettler of protecting the infamous "Rooiwal 5" – a group of senior officials within Tshwane implicated in wrongdoing relating to the tender. The municipality has been engaged in a protracted labour dispute with the employees.
ALLEGATION 7: FIRING OF 44-STRIKING WORKERS
In 2023, the Tshwane Municipality was almost brought to its knees by a three-month labour strike.
The municipality had refused to institute a previously agreed upon salary increase, leading to workers taking to the streets.
The strike was disruptive, with service delivery on pause, municipal vehicles torched and several incidents of the city’s infrastructure being vandalised.
In the aftermath of the unprotected strike, the municipality fired 44 of its employees on various charges, including vandalism, incitement of violence and misconduct.
In its complaint, the EFF believes Mettler didn’t follow due process when signing off on the dismissal of the workers.
“No reliable record was produced identifying which employee committed which act of alleged misconduct, on what date, on what evidence, or following what disciplinary process,” reads the letter.
“The dismissals were effected and defended on the strength of generalised, unsubstantiated and in material respects inaccurate assertions.”
Earlier this year, the Tshwane Municipality announced it had reached an agreement with worker unions to pay R1 billion in backdated increases to workers.
POLITICAL FALLOUT FROM ANC, EFF AND ACTIONSA
The ANC and EFF have been public about their desire to remove Mettler as the Tshwane Municipality City Manager.
Their coalition partner, ActionSA, has been coy on the matter.
The party didn’t respond to EWN’s request for a comment on this story.
Meanwhile, Joel Masilela, ANC Tshwane Spokesperson, has welcomed the complaint, saying it's high time the council investigates Mettler.
“His head must be chopped, and we must make sure we find a capable candidate to lead the city in the direction and trajectory we have set ourselves,” he said.