Disgraced Eastern Cape Judge President Selby Mbenenge has asked the Pretoria High Court to stop the Judicial Service Commission (JSC) and Parliament from acting against him until a review of the JSC's gross misconduct finding is finalised.
Mbenenge has filed papers at the court challenging the JSC's decision, describing it as irrational, procedurally unfair and inconsistent with the principle of legality.
ALSO READ:
Mbenenge fights impeachment, labels JSC's sexual harassment ruling irrational and unprocedural
Mbenenge launches bid challenging JSC’s gross misconduct finding
Mbenenge doesn't appreciate responsibility associated with his position: JSC
The application stems from sexual harassment allegations made against him by his former secretary, Andiswa Mengo.
Mbenenge seeks to have the JSC's finding of gross misconduct reviewed and set aside, while also asking the court to interdict the JSC from taking further steps and to prevent Parliament from considering the matter pending the outcome of the review proceedings.
Mbenenge argues that it is unprecedented for the JSC to replace the tribunal's finding of misconduct, which does not carry the consequence of impeachment, with gross misconduct.
In court papers, he said this is procedurally unfair, substantively irrational, materially influenced by errors of law and fact, unreasonable and offends the principle of legality.
He argues the finding against him didn’t meet the test for sexual harassment, as it was based on WhatsApp texts and not on actual sexual intercourse or persistent humiliating or threatening actions.
Mbenenge said Article 5.1 of the Code of Judicial Conduct cannot be used against him, as he was not given an opportunity to bring a defence in relation this section.
He has urged the court to consider that the complainant, Mengo, was found to have lied and omitted flirtatious messages she had sent and claiming to be an unwilling participant, resulting in a damning credibility finding against her.
Mbenenge wants the impeachment process against him stayed, pending the finalisation of the review.