Eastern Cape Judge President Selby Mbenenge has described the Judicial Service Commission's (JSC) ruling against him as irrational, unprocedural, and inconsistent with the principle of legality.
Mbenenge has approached the Pretoria High Court to review the JSC's finding of gross misconduct against him. The finding stems from allegations of sexual harassment made by his former secretary, Andiswa Mengo.
As part of his application, Mbenenge wants the High Court to interdict the JSC from taking further action against him and to stop Parliament from proceeding with any disciplinary steps until the review is finalised. He is seeking a formal stay of the entire impeachment process pending the final outcome of this legal challenge.
READ MORE:
Robes and reputations: The tribunal of Eastern Cape Judge President, Selby Mbenenge
High Court secretary tells tribunal EC Judge President Mbenenge sent her explicit videos
Tribunal hearing into EC Judge President Mbenenge's sex harassment matter to be held publicly
Judge Mbenenge argues that it is unprecedented for the JSC to replace a Judicial Conduct Tribunal's finding of misconduct — which does not carry the consequence of impeachment — with a finding of gross misconduct.
In his court papers, he alleges that the commission's decision was procedurally unfair, substantively irrational, materially influenced by errors of law and fact, unreasonable, and offensive to the principle of legality. He is asking the court to review and set aside the ruling based on these legal principles.
Furthermore, Mbenenge argues that the finding against him did not meet the legal test for sexual harassment. He points out that the case was based entirely on WhatsApp texts rather than actual sexual intercourse or persistent humiliating or threatening actions.
He also asserts that Article 5.1 of the Code of Judicial Conduct cannot be applied against him in this instance, as he was never allowed to present a proper defence in relation to that specific section.
Finally, Mbenenge has urged the court to take into account that the complainant, Andiswa Mengo, was found to have lied and omitted flirtatious messages she had previously sent. He states that her claims of being an unwilling participant resulted in a damning credibility finding against her during the initial inquiry.