The defence in the tribunal investigating racism allegations against an Eastern Cape judge is expected to present video evidence that it said could challenge the complainant’s account of events.

High Court Judge Belinda Hartle is accused of repeatedly swearing at court clerk Thozamile Semekazi and using the K-word during a May 2025 incident at the East London High Court.

ALSO READ: Complainant wraps up testimony in Judge Hartle racism tribunal

Hartle denies using the racial slur, but admits to swearing, insisting it was not directed at Semekazi.

The Judicial Conduct Tribunal in Sandton is hearing evidence in the gross misconduct case.

The incident dates back to 15 May 2025, when Semekazi delivered case files to Hartle’s office after computer problems delayed their compilation.

He alleges the judge became angry and verbally abused him in front of her secretary.

Semekazi said the incident left him traumatised, claiming he was hospitalised the following day and diagnosed with major depressive disorder.

The tribunal has also heard evidence about WhatsApp messages in which Hartle apologised for swearing and referred to leaving a peace offering on his desk.

Hartle’s representative, Advocate Chris Heunis, has also suggested that the complaint was retaliation following a newspaper article by Hartle’s husband, journalist Ray Hartle, which referred to allegations that Semekazi had solicited bribes. He denies this.

“I had never called Ray Hartle in March of 2024,” Semekazi denied.

Heunis challenged, “He also has a recording of that call.”

Semekazi became emotional when questioned about his medical history and divorce, prompting Tribunal president Justice Boissie Mbha to question the line of questioning.

Never miss a major story. Get breaking news and the latest developments from South Africa and beyond as they happen.