The lawyer representing alleged crime kingpin Vusimuzi “Cat” Matlala has criticised the Madlanga Commission’s evidence leaders for questioning her client about what she said was an off-the-record discussion.

The dispute relates to a statement and report compiled by the commission’s investigator following an interview with Matlala in March.

ALSO READ:

Matlala claims he was heavily medicated when he alleged paying Sibiya R500k

Madlanga Commission hears IDAC officials took Matlala to hotel instead of prison

Madlanga Commission rejects Matlala's bid to block plea agreement questions

Evidence leaders maintain that both the commission’s legal team and Matlala’s legal representatives were present during the session.

However, Matlala’s advocate, Annelene van den Heever, said there was an understanding that the discussion was off-the-record and should, therefore, not have been used to cross-examine her client.

Van den Heever said she is appalled that the contents of the engagement have now featured in proceedings.

"I want to place on record that my client should never have been confronted with what happened off the record, but what was agreed by this commission's evidence leaders was an off-the-record discussion.

"Under no circumstances do we do that, because this is what distinguishes us from other people out there, and you commissioner, chair, I've seen you before. You are quite strenuous and strict on ethics."

NO VALUE IN CONDUCTING AN OFF-THE-RECORD CONSULTATION

Madlanga Commission evidence leader Advocate Mahlape Sello said there would have been no value in conducting an off-the-record consultation with Matlala.

This follows a dispute over a March meeting between Matlala and the Madlanga Commission’s investigator.

During the meeting, Matlala allegedly told the investigator he had given former Police Commissioner Shadrack Sibiya R500,000.

Sello has rejected this version and said Matlala’s legal representatives were not available for the consultation and later indicated they would not participate in any further consultations.

Sello said Van den Heever’s account is inaccurate, as she was not present at the meeting.

“Now, Ms Van den Heever here suggests that between myself, Advocate Hassim and herself, we agreed that those consultations were of the record. We could never. We did not. And we indeed could never. Because if they were off the record, there would have been no necessity for the investigator to be present in those consultations.”

APOLOGY DEMANDS

Advocates representing the Madlanga Commission and Matlala are seeking apologies from each other following the dispute over the alleged off-the-record consultation.

Advocate Sello has demanded an apology from Advocate Van den Heever, after she accused her of ethical misconduct.

Sello said she was not present at the meeting where Van den Heever claims it was communicated that the discussions with Matlala were off the record.

Van den Heever has also indicated that she wants an apology for being painted as being dishonest.

Chairperson Mbuyiseli Madlanga has ordered that Matlala’s testimony continue.

“I don't think we should stretch it please. If you say Ms Hassim, then Ms Hassim is not here. Let's proceed on the basis on which I rule we should. So, Ms Hassim is not here. I'm not sure who you want to attend the apology now. I think we've reached a stage where we should proceed.”

Never miss a major story. Get breaking news and the latest developments from South Africa and beyond as they happen.