A document allegedly showing how Richard Mdluli diverted money meant for Crime Intelligence vehicles to settle his own car finance has triggered a dispute in the Pretoria High Court, where Mdluli and his co-accused are facing graft charges.
The clash erupted on Monday during a trial-within-a-trial to determine whether the document and other evidence are admissible as evidence, with the court examining whether it was lawfully obtained and seized.
ALSO READ:
Former Crime Intelligence head Mdluli’s corruption trial set to proceed
Court hears how SSA was made to pay for Richard Mdluli’s lifestyle expenses
Court hears details of expenses corruption-accused Richard Mdluli ran up on overseas trips
At the centre of the dispute is a document allegedly found at Mdluli's Brackenfell property.
It relates to two vehicles purchased for Crime Intelligence by Mdluli and his co-accused.
The State alleges that money saved through a discount on the vehicles was never returned to Crime Intelligence.
Instead, Mdluli allegedly used it to settle his own vehicle finance.
The vehicles were reportedly in the possession of Mdluli's wife and registered in her name, despite belonging to Crime Intelligence.
Defence counsel Ameline Roestorf objected to the State's line of questioning of its witness, a retired police officer, arguing that it was venturing into the merits of the case.
The State, however, insisted that the questions were necessary to establish the witness's bona fides, including what information had been shared with him and his conduct before the seizure.
Judge John Holland-Mutter agreed, stressing that the proceedings must remain focused on the lawfulness of the seizure.
The documents have also been subject to prolonged legal wrangling over their classification, contributing to the delay, though they have since been declassified.
Never miss a major story. Get breaking news and the latest developments from South Africa and beyond as they happen.