The African National Congress (ANC) could be heading for an even more dramatic electoral collapse in 2029, with political analyst Prince Mashele predicting the party will be lucky to secure 15% of the vote.

Mashele, who correctly predicted that the ANC would lose its electoral majority in 2024, says corruption, incompetence and arrogance have driven voters away from the governing party.

Speaking to Bongani Bingwa on 702, Mashele argued that the latest election results reflected a clear message from voters: they no longer wanted the ANC in government.

The party secured 30.7% of the national vote, marking a significant decline from the approximately 70% it received at its peak in 2004 under former president Thabo Mbeki.

Asked what the figures meant for the ANC's prospects in the 2029 national and provincial elections, Mashele was unequivocal.

"Mark my words, Bongani, the ANC in 2029 will be lucky to get 15%," he said.

He dismissed suggestions that his predictions were prophetic, insisting they were based on political science and an assessment of electoral trends.

"I've studied political science. There are methods to this. And people think that I just suck my thumb and tell them a number. No. I study this stuff and look at scenarios and arrive at scientifically informed conclusions," Mashele said.

He pointed to his earlier prediction that the ANC would lose an election in 2024, which he and Professor Mzukisi Qobo had written about in their book The Fall of the ANC, written in 2012 and published in 2014.

Related articles:

— South Africa unlikely to see one-party rule again, says Roelf Meyer

— Mantashe says ANC's electoral decline is a sign of South Africa's maturing democracy

— After the local elections: The ANC blame game and complex coalition talks to come

— ANC blames ActionSA for declining electoral support in Gauteng townships

Political analyst on who holds the key to South Africa’s future

Video · Brightcove player not connected in this prototype

Corruption, incompetence and arrogance have 'killed' the ANC

Mashele identified three fundamental problems that he believes have brought the ANC to its current position: corruption, incompetence and arrogance.

He said these would ultimately define the party's decline when historians came to write its history.

"The ANC, when it's finally buried, on its tombstone, three diseases will be recorded that have killed the ANC. Disease number one is corruption. Disease number two is incompetence. Disease number three is arrogance," he said.

According to Mashele, voters have delivered a clear verdict on the party's performance.

"They said to the ANC, we no longer want you as our government," he said.

He was also dismissive of the idea that President Cyril Ramaphosa could have rescued the organisation when he took over its leadership in 2018, despite the initial optimism surrounding his presidency and the so-called Ramaphoria.

Mashele argued that the ANC's problems were too deeply entrenched for any individual to reverse its decline.

"The ANC is a rotten corpse. Anyone who goes in there will stink," he said.

He added that Ramaphosa had inherited an organisation that was beyond repair and that joining it had ultimately damaged his own political standing.

"There was absolutely no way that he would turn it around. So, the best thing he should have done at that moment would have been to stay away from this rotten carcass," Mashele said.

He believes Ramaphosa will be remembered as the president who presided over the party's demise.

"He is now left without any credibility, and he will go down in history as someone who has presided over the funeral of that party," he said.

ANC failed to prepare for the transition from liberation movement to governing party

Mashele also agreed with the argument that liberation movements tend to lose their political dominance after approximately 25 to 30 years in power unless they successfully transform into modern political parties.

He put the average lifespan of such movements in power at around 28 years, arguing that their fundamental weakness is that they are not necessarily equipped to govern when they take office.

"Here is the inherent DNA weakness of liberation movements. They are never trained to govern," he said.

Mashele argued that liberation movements concentrate on fighting for political freedom without adequately preparing for the practical responsibilities of running a government.

He challenged the suggestion that the ANC had prepared itself for governance through its policy documents before 1994.

He pointed out that the ANC's Ready to Govern document was written after 1994, arguing that the organisation had not adequately prepared itself for the task of governing before taking power.

"These fellows had never spent a minute thinking about how to govern," he said.

Mashele further argued that corruption was not unique to African liberation movements, pointing to similar patterns among liberation movements and former revolutionary organisations elsewhere in the world.

He said these two weaknesses — inadequate preparation for governing and susceptibility to corruption — made it difficult for liberation movements to evolve into effective modern governing parties.

Mashele challenges claims that ANC transformation policies benefited the majority

The political analyst also disputed the suggestion that some former ANC voters who had switched their support to Herman Mashaba's ActionSA might eventually regret their decision because of the party's opposition to policies such as black economic empowerment (BEE) and employment equity.

Mashele rejected the idea that the ANC's transformation policies had substantially benefited the majority of Black South Africans.

"The BEE of the ANC and the affirmative action of the ANC, the policies, actually have not benefited the majority of South Africans," he said.

He challenged Bingwa to look at communities such as Soweto and Tembisa and assess whether ordinary residents had experienced the benefits of those policies.

According to Mashele, the benefits had largely accrued to a connected Black elite rather than the broader population.

"These benefits have been seen by the Black elite who actually live in Sandton. And in the main, those connected to the African National Congress," he said.

He argued that voters who had moved their support to ActionSA understood that the political establishment was not necessarily representing their interests.

Bingwa pushed back, arguing that the transformation agenda had never been intended as a quick solution to the structural economic inequalities inherited by the democratic government.

Mashele rejected that interpretation, saying the ANC had explicitly presented its transformation agenda as a means of empowering the majority of Black South Africans and transforming the economy.

He argued that the party had failed to deliver on those promises, fuelling voter dissatisfaction in communities such as Soweto, Tembisa and Daveyton.

'Losers who want to regroup in order to continue to loot'

Mashele was particularly scathing about suggestions that the ANC could form a so-called left-wing or Black political alliance with parties including the Economic Freedom Fighters (EFF), uMkhonto weSizwe (MK) and the South African Communist Party (SACP).

He questioned whether the political labels attached to some of these parties accurately reflected their ideologies or conduct.

"There's absolutely nothing left about the EFF," he said, questioning the lifestyle and wealth of its leader, Julius Malema.

Mashele also rejected the suggestion that MK represented Black political interests, arguing that its leaders were more concerned with their own enrichment.

He warned South Africans against being persuaded by the language of political solidarity and ideological alignment.

"These are losers who want to regroup in order for them to continue to loot," he said.

DA and ActionSA coalition could be best outcome for Gauteng

Looking beyond the ANC's electoral prospects, Mashele argued that the most positive outcome for South Africa would be coalition governments involving the Democratic Alliance (DA) and ActionSA in Gauteng's three major metropolitan municipalities: Tshwane, Ekurhuleni and Johannesburg.

He said Gauteng was central to the country's economic wellbeing and that the failure of its major cities would have serious consequences for the rest of the country.

"Gauteng is the heart of South Africa, as we all know, economically. It is important for the metros in Gauteng to work in order for South Africa to work. If things collapse in Gauteng, the rest of South Africa collapses," he said.

However, such an arrangement could be complicated by disagreements over political leadership.

Mashaba has indicated that he would not enter into a coalition arrangement with the DA if Helen Zille remained at the helm.

Mashele criticised this position, drawing a comparison with the EFF's refusal to support a DA-led coalition in Johannesburg in 2016 if Mashaba was its mayoral candidate.

He argued that both Mashaba and Zille needed to put personal differences aside in the interests of the cities and their residents.

"This is not about personalities. This is about the life of a city and the life of ordinary South Africans. So, at some point, they will have to mature," he said.

Mashele maintained that the electoral arithmetic made cooperation between the DA and ActionSA a viable option, arguing that the parties had enough combined support to govern.

Ultimately, he said, coalition negotiations should reflect voters' choices rather than the personal preferences of individual political leaders.

"The voters have spoken," he said.

Never miss a major story. Get breaking news and the latest developments from South Africa and beyond as they happen.