The Democratic Alliance (DA) has been ordered to take down all its billboards and social media posts associating three eThekwini Municipality officials with the water tanker mafia.
On 28 September, the DA unveiled a huge election billboard along the N2 highway near Newlands East in Durban.
The billboard featured the faces of eThekwini mayor Cyril Xaba, city manager Sipho Mbhele, and the municipality’s water and sanitation executive director, Ednick Msweli.
ALSO READ: eThekwini officials threaten legal action over DA's 'water tanker mafia' billboard
It was accompanied by the caption "you can stop the water tanker mafia" and "vote DA for water in your taps."
While the billboard was later taken down by the advertising company, the three municipal officials took the DA to court, saying the billboard was defamatory.
In his ruling today, Acting Judge DJ Nzimande agreed.
"I therefore find that the post complained of is extremely damaging to the applicants (three municipal officials) and the position they hold in society. The continued publication and circulation of the damaging statements undoubtedly lead to a lack of trust as the municipality’s leaders. Consequently, I find that harm has been committed against the applicants," said Nzimande.
The Durban High Court ruled that the DA billboard associating the three eThekwini Municipality officials with the water tanker mafia went beyond the limits of free speech.
In a ruling handed down earlier on Wednesday, Judge Nzimande said free speech also comes with the responsibility not to defame people.
"Nothing in this order prevents the respondents [the DA] from criticising the applicants [the municipality officials] or any of them for the performance of their functions, the state of water services and infrastructure, the procurement and management of water tankers, the findings of the Auditor-General or any other public body, or their remuneration, or from campaigning on those matters," Judge Nzimande added.
Never miss a major story. Get breaking news and the latest developments from South Africa and beyond as they happen.