Former Deputy National Police Commissioner Shadrack Sibiya has been denied bail.

The Randburg Magistrates Court found that Sibiya failed to prove beyond reasonable doubt that he would not interfere with the case if released from custody.

The 59-year-old is accused of sexually grooming a 16-year-old minor and raping an 18-year-old.

ALSO READ:

Judgment expected in rape-accused Shadrack Sibiya’s bail bid

Shadrack Sibiya bail hearing: Defence lawyer questions human trafficking charge

State pokes holes in Sibiya’s denial of intimidating potential witnesses

‘Nothing exceptional’ about complainants saying they live in constant fear, argues Sibiya’s lawyer

He faces charges including rape, sexual grooming, human trafficking, and negligent handling of a firearm.

During Sibiya's bail application, the State argued that the former top cop is in a position to interfere with his criminal case if granted bail.

The State said Sibiya held the second-highest position in the police service, giving him the power and influence to sway the case in his favour.

It further argued that Sibiya could intimidate the victims and witnesses, claiming that some of his close friends have already attempted to do so.

But in her judgment, Magistrate Hleziphi Mkhasibe emphasised that the friends acted independently in their attempts to intimidate the victims, and not on his instructions.

However, she also found that Sibiya had, indeed, threatened the father of the 16-year-old he is accused of sexually grooming, despite the defence’s claim that no threats were made.

“The second threat establishes a dangerous pattern of behaviour. It shows intent, meaning the person was not just having a momentary lapse of judgment the first time. They genuinely mean to cause harm.”

The magistrate delivered judgment: “The finding of the court is that the applicant failed to show exceptional circumstances that permit his release on bail. As a result, he’ll remain in custody.”

SIBIYA WAS AWARE THAT HE WAS COMMITTING A CRIME: MAGISTRATE

The Randburg Magistrates Court further found that Sibiya knew he was committing a crime when he allegedly sexually groomed a 16-year-old girl.

In its ruling on his bail application, the court said Sibiya wiped his cellphone, apparently to conceal explicit WhatsApp chats with the minor.

Mkhasibe said this suggests Sibiya was aware that he was committing a crime.

“As a high-ranking police officer at the time, he was aware that he’s committing a crime. He was also aware that he’s tampering with evidence that has a potential of implicating him. In my mind, the accused will go to any lengths and/or there is no end to what he will do to tamper with evidence that implicates him.”

She outlined her views on Sibiya, asking the minor to delete their WhatsApp exchange.

The applicant requested that the child victim delete their conversation. This demonstrates that the victim is vulnerable. His actions give us a window into his intention.

Sibiya will return to court on 24 November.

Never miss a major story. Get breaking news and the latest developments from South Africa and beyond as they happen.