Political parties are divided over Thursday’s Constitutional Court ruling that compels the Electoral Commission of South Africa (IEC) to add 181 African National Congress (ANC) candidates to the ballots of six municipalities, after the party missed the IEC’s deadline for finalising lists.
While the Democratic Alliance (DA), the uMKhonto weSizwe Party (MKP) and Freedom Front (FF) Plus are among parties that are unhappy about the decision, the United Democratic Movement (UDM) has welcomed the ruling, saying it presents the opportunity for the IEC to refine its electronic candidate nomination system.
ALSO READ:
IEC to amend ballots after ConCourt rules in favour of ANC in candidate list dispute
ANC wins battle against IEC over candidates lists debacle
The court is yet to give reasons for its decision, but the DA, which was the only party to challenge the ANC’s appeal application, said that it sets a concerning precedent for respecting the IEC’s deadlines and requirements.
The ANC has been successful in overturning an Electoral Court ruling after challenging the purpose of a “submit as final” button on the IEC’s electronic nomination system, arguing that it had already uploaded all the details of the candidates it wanted to field in the affected municipalities at the hour of cut-off.
But the MKP said the judgment raises serious questions about equality before the law and it’s insisting that other qualifying parties be afforded the same treatment.
The Electoral Commission previously indicated that more than 40 parties had not locked in the uploaded candidate information as final by the August deadline.
Meanwhile, the FF Plus said that while it doesn’t lack respect for the judiciary, it finds the ruling strange and problematic.
Party leader Corne Mulder said with the court paving the way for the ANC to contest the Mangaung metro despite its administrative failures in that municipality, voters should be more discerning when considering the list debacle.
“Votes must be earned, and the ANC has repeatedly shown that it does not deserve the trust and support of the people of South Africa,” said Mulder.
The African Christian Democratic Party (ACDP)’s Steve Swart has likened the ANC’s ruling to its own experience twenty years ago when the Constitutional Court found in the party’s favour after the IEC said it had not paid its electoral deposits to contest the Cape Town metro.
The ACDP went on to form part of the governing coalition with the DA that unseated the ANC in the city.
“Our experience demonstrated that electoral disputes often have consequences far beyond the parties directly involved – here, the broader Cape Town area, never again to be governed by the ANC.”
However, Swart said that with the ANC’s declining electoral support, he didn’t expect the court ruling to have a significant impact on its performance at the ballot box.
Never miss a major story. Get breaking news and the latest developments from South Africa and beyond as they happen.